|
|
Subscribe / Log in / New account

The new Fedora Project mission statement

The Fedora Project has come up with a new mission statement: "Fedora creates an innovative platform that lights up hardware, clouds, and containers for software developers and community members to build tailored solutions for their users." See the full text for a description of what it means and how they arrived at it.


From:  Matthew Miller <mattdm-AT-fedoraproject.org>
To:  Discussions with the Fedora Council and community <council-discuss-AT-lists.fedoraproject.org>
Subject:  Updating the Fedora Project Mission
Date:  Fri, 14 Apr 2017 09:55:13 -0400
Message-ID:  <20170414135513.GA14311@mattdm.org>

Background
----------

Way back in 2003, the original Fedora Project mission statement¹ was
straightforward — “to work with the Linux community to build a
complete, general purpose operating system exclusively from open
source software.” This has some virtue: it's clear and concrete, and
it encodes the values of community and open source. But, it's also
rather small; arguably this was _already done_, so, you know, “good
job everyone” — backslapping ensues, nothing more needed, right?

After 6½ years, the Fedora Board (the precursor to our current Fedora
Council) decided it was time for a refresh, and put a lot of work
into coming up with our current mission² (as well as a vision and
objectives). That mission is “to lead the advancement of free and
open source software and content as a collaborative community.”

This has many virtues too — it's ambitious, and again keeps those key
values front and center. But, it's also very broad. If we were to
start a project with a clean slate today to do what the mission says,
I don't think we'd even _think_ of creating a Linux distro. There are
plenty of other activities that could consume an entire large
pro-free-and-open-source project.

When we started Fedora.next, we decided to work underneath the
mission as it stood. This has worked out well enough, but we're
coming up to what feels like the limit. This is clear in the
"Budget.next" process — it's one thing to say that spending is to be
determined in public based on clear objectives and measurable
results, but for it to really work, those objectives need to be
attached to a goal with a more clear scope.

It's now been another 6½ years, and it’s the perfect time to revisit
the mission — to look at who we are, what we do well, what we really
want to do, what we say we do but actually don't, and so on.


Our Thinking
------------

At our in-person activity days at the end of March, the Fedora
Council did just that. We spent some time discussing those questions
and worked on lists of strengths, weaknesses, threats, and
opportunities. We talked about the Fedora Foundations as well, and
agreed that we do want to keep these as statements of our core
values. We wanted something which would answer:

  * What do we do?

  * How do we do it?

  * Who do we do it for?

  * and, what unique value do we bring?

After a long and productive working discussion, we decided to break
for dinner, and come back the next morning to actually draft a new
statement to bring to the community for discussion, adjustment, and
approval. Brian scribbled down a quick idea in the evening, and in
the morning we started bright and early at adding to, subtracting
from, rewording, deconstructing, and reconstructing, until we came up
with something that everyone on the Council felt good about.


The New Mission Draft
---------------------

So, here it is:

  Fedora creates an innovative platform that lights up hardware,
  clouds, and containers for software developers and community
  members to build tailored solutions for their users.


Let's Break It Down
-------------------

We decided to not write a new vision statement at this point. The
Four Foundations³ — Freedom, Friends, Features, First — both state
our core values and illustrate our overall goals and objectives.
However, we do want to make sure that some of the various parts of
the mission are explained.

  * Creates an innovative platform — at the operating system level,
    we don’t just integrate.We do new things.  This is what makes
    us a platform and not just a distribution. And, “innovative” is
    just a buzzword. Current examples include solving the “too fast
    / too slow” problem with Modularity, exploring ostree for
    delivery and updates, and the Layered Image Build Service,
    where containers become a first-class part of the OS.

  - Lights up hardware, clouds, and containers — We want to be
    specific about a primary focus as an enablement layer for
    environments people want to use.

  - For software developers to build tailored solutions for their
    users — this includes both upstream software developers and
    downstream communities who want to build on what we create.

  - For community members to build tailored solutions for their
    users — Fedora isn’t just the toolkit. Many of our contributors
    are here to collaborate to create solutions for specific user
    problems, ranging from Fedora Workstation to Fedora Robotics
    Suite. We have lots of ways to do this within the project, from
    Editions to Spins and Labs to the upcoming Fedora Playground
    concept. The core emphasis, though, is on enabling this
    collaboration.


Next Steps
----------

We really hope our proposed mission statement makes sense to all of
you and tries to capture what we want to be for the next three to
five years. We would be very interested in feedback from the
community, not just in how to make the language tighter but, truly,
on the goals of the project and how we can better capture the ethos
of Fedora.

 
----

1. http://web.archive.org/web/20031008035915/http://fedora.r...
2. https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Overview#Our_Mission
3. https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Foundations

-- 
Matthew Miller
<mattdm@fedoraproject.org>
Fedora Project Leader
_______________________________________________
council-discuss mailing list -- council-discuss@lists.fedoraproject.org
To unsubscribe send an email to council-discuss-leave@lists.fedoraproject.org


to post comments

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 14, 2017 18:03 UTC (Fri) by atai (subscriber, #10977) [Link] (4 responses)

There seems to be missing: dedication to FOSS

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 14, 2017 20:00 UTC (Fri) by louie (guest, #3285) [Link]

That's in the Four Foundations, but it would be nice to be clearer how those interact.

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 14, 2017 23:44 UTC (Fri) by rgmoore (✭ supporter ✭, #75) [Link] (2 responses)

This could be easily fixed by specifying "innovative free software platform" or "innovative FOSS platform" in the first clause.

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 15, 2017 13:58 UTC (Sat) by mattdm (subscriber, #18) [Link] (1 responses)

If we say "free software" without "open source", it gives the appearance of taking particular sides in that argument, which we want to stay above. Or, "open source" without "free software". If we say FOSS (or FLOSS), we immediately cut down the audience for which the statement has any meaning to a small in-group. If we spell it all out, the statement loses any hope at directness.

That's why we decided we'd instead make the Fedora Foundations — of which "freedom" is the first — prominent in place of a vision statement, right next to the mission. It gives us a lot more room to illustrate what we actually mean.

I'm open to revisiting that, but that's the thinking we had. We certainly have no intention of deemphasizing software freedom as part of the overall project strategy.

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 18, 2017 10:24 UTC (Tue) by BeS (guest, #43108) [Link]

> If we say "free software" without "open source", it gives the appearance of taking particular sides in that argument

I don't think it is about taking sides. Both Free Software and Open Source describes the same software. It's just about which aspects you want to highlight, is it more the technical part of the availability of source code or the social part of software freedom.

While personal I prefer to highlight the "not so technical" aspects of software freedom I wouldn't mind if Fedora would decide to highlight the "open" part. As said by others, I wouldn't go with "FOSS", "FLOSS", "free and open source",... that's all to technical and to confusing. But I would appreciate it if "Open Source" or "Free Software" would be part of the mission statement.

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 14, 2017 18:46 UTC (Fri) by dowdle (subscriber, #659) [Link] (1 responses)

They said, 'And, “innovative” is just a buzzword.'... but I'm guessing they meant to put a NOT in there.

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 15, 2017 13:44 UTC (Sat) by mattdm (subscriber, #18) [Link]

LOL. Yes. Fun with editing.

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 14, 2017 21:11 UTC (Fri) by jbowen (subscriber, #113501) [Link] (8 responses)

I feel the new statement leaves out the segment of people who just use Fedora as their everyday general purpose operating system.

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 15, 2017 8:27 UTC (Sat) by csamuel (✭ supporter ✭, #2624) [Link] (7 responses)

I have to agree, it's almost "Fedora: it's no longer for the desktop" (rather than "Fedora: it's no longer _just_ for the desktop").

Not personally a Fedora user, but I still care about it and I'd hope this doesn't reflect a move away from meeting the needs of those users.

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 15, 2017 16:48 UTC (Sat) by yodermk (subscriber, #3803) [Link] (6 responses)

Agreed. I *am* a Fedora user on the desktop (well actually laptops, my desktop runs Arch :) ). I very much support the idea of Fedora being the best desktop distro it can be.

OTOH, I am also a developer/engineer/sysadmin, so I guess I appreciate the whole package Fedora offers.

Maybe the point is that for non-tech end users, Fedora simply isn't the right choice? Maybe, but I don't think there's any reason it can't work well for them.

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 16, 2017 12:38 UTC (Sun) by mattdm (subscriber, #18) [Link] (5 responses)

To quote myself...

> Fedora isn’t just the toolkit. Many of our contributors
> are here to collaborate to create solutions for specific user
> problems, ranging from Fedora Workstation to Fedora Robotics
> Suite. We have lots of ways to do this within the project, from
> Editions to Spins and Labs to the upcoming Fedora Playground
> concept. The core emphasis, though, is on enabling this
> collaboration.

This mission statement is not an end-user marketing message; it's meant to help guide the project itself (as well as potential collaborators and contributors). Separately, we want to have stronger distinct marketing around Fedora Workstation, Fedora Atomic, Fedora Server — and all the various Spins. Many of these *do* have a direct end-user focus. We've seen a marked increase in various metrics since we started this organizational and marketing split with Fedora.next, and we want to build on that.

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 17, 2017 18:19 UTC (Mon) by Conan_Kudo (subscriber, #103240) [Link] (4 responses)

The thing is, when you're making a change like this, everything matters to everyone. And messages as simple as the mission statement need to be necessarily broad to cover everything Fedora as a project does and will do. It's a bad idea to write something like that in a way that makes what the vast majority of people care about feel like their work is not important anymore.

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 17, 2017 21:44 UTC (Mon) by mattdm (subscriber, #18) [Link] (3 responses)

Well, yes, doing what you say certainly sounds like it would be a bad idea. But I'm think you've lost me. How do you think what we've drafted is related to that, and why?

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 17, 2017 22:08 UTC (Mon) by rahulsundaram (subscriber, #21946) [Link] (1 responses)

Essentially, the feedback you have been getting is very consistent

1) You are not mentioning free and open source software and people are worried that it implies that the project isn't going to focus on that
2) Desktop/laptop users are feeling left out

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 24, 2017 15:29 UTC (Mon) by mattdm (subscriber, #18) [Link]

> 1) You are not mentioning free and open source software and people are worried that it implies that the project isn't going to focus on that

I understand the worry, but I think it's mostly because I took it for granted and didn't emphasize it in this message. The intention is for the core values, including Freedom, to be emphasized along with the mission statement.

> 2) Desktop/laptop users are feeling left out

That's okay. This isn't a marketing message for users. Desktop/laptop users will continue to be an important base served through Fedora Workstation and the desktop spins.

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 18, 2017 14:37 UTC (Tue) by csamuel (✭ supporter ✭, #2624) [Link]

The document says that the mission statement should say (amongst other things):

# * What do we do?
#
# * Who do we do it for?

When desktop/laptop users (etc) are ommitted then you are saying that they are not part of what you are doing, or your target audience.

Now that might not be what you *mean* to be saying, but sadly it is (IMHO) what you are actually saying.

All the best,
Chris

The new Fedora Project mission statement

Posted Apr 18, 2017 10:29 UTC (Tue) by BeS (guest, #43108) [Link] (1 responses)

> Lights up hardware, clouds, and containers

For my taste that's to specific. Already one year from now there might be another "cool" and important technology and another year later nobody (or significant less people) will care about one of the three you mention here.

Why not something more technology neutral and long lasting like: "Fedora creates an innovative platform for general purpose computers and servers..."

General Purpose Computers as Servers Scare People

Posted Apr 27, 2017 4:46 UTC (Thu) by Garak (guest, #99377) [Link]

The answer is simple- people are scared of what terrorists and pedophiles can do with General Purpose Computers and Servers and the Internet. As importantly, so are establishment businesses whose product's functionality can be subsumed by those things. If you want to get nostalgic, read about General Purpose technologies in FCC-10-201 (U.S. net neutrality circa 2010). Then compare the language to whatever lauded internet policy comes out of the current and future administrations. And contrast with what is really going on for industry and individual users. Google and Amazon and a few others are the gatekeepers. The sad truth is that the democratic majority wants gatekeepers and censors... at the same time they want to hear about how much freedom from gatekeepers and censorship their policies provide. Contradictory? sure. Avoidable or changeable? I'm not so sure anymore.

http://apps.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/view?id=7522219498


Copyright © 2017, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds