A Turing award for Michael Stonebraker

Posted Apr 15, 2015 12:20 UTC (Wed) by nye (subscriber, #51576)
In reply to: A Turing award for Michael Stonebraker by misterbonnie
Parent article: A Turing award for Michael Stonebraker

>Hrm, "open software"?

Seems accurate enough to me: Ingres wasn't released as Open Source or Free Software, because neither term had been coined at that time. Using a generic umbrella term 'open software' to describe Ingres and Postgres seems entirely reasonable for those who aren't particularly in it for the politics.

A Turing award for Michael Stonebraker

Posted Apr 15, 2015 13:23 UTC (Wed) by intgr (subscriber, #39733) [Link]

Stonebraker makes money by developing "open software" at universities and then turning them into proprietary products. Ingres was developed at Berkeley and then commercialized by Actian Corporation. Postgres was developed at Berkeley and then sold as Illustra. H-Store was developed jointly by a few universities and then sold as VoltDB.

It seems to me that he deliberately avoids any hint of involvement in open source software or PostgreSQL. The Turing award press release didn't even mention PostgreSQL, but did mention Greenplum, one of its proprietary forks. The most direct reference that Stonebraker has made to PostgreSQL, that I know of, is belittling relational databases as "the elephants" in VoltDB marketing documents. (http://downloads.voltdb.com/datasheets_collateral/vdb_web...)

Now, none of this takes away from his achievement of being involved in so many influential database projects. But make no mistake, he is definitely not a proponent of open source software. The fact that independent volunteers picked up the original POSTGRES code dump and turned it into a successful open source project, was incidential.