A GPL-enforcement suit against VMware

Posted Mar 13, 2015 22:08 UTC (Fri) by jra (subscriber, #55261)
In reply to: A GPL-enforcement suit against VMware by dlang
Parent article: A GPL-enforcement suit against VMware

I work in Google's Open Source Programs Office reporting to Chris. I've *given* the training you're talking about. You are wrong. You need to pass review to import *any* open source code into Google, and GPLv3 is treated no differently than any other code under a copy left license.

Stop hijacking threads to make them about your personal hobby-horse of how much you dislike GPLv3. I'm sick of it. This thread is about the VMware lawsuit. Let's keep it on topic.

A GPL-enforcement suit against VMware

Posted Mar 13, 2015 22:18 UTC (Fri) by dlang (guest, #313) [Link] (4 responses)

calm down, I wasn't the one who accused Google of not liking the GPL, I actually spoke up to say that Google was not anti-GPL. I was defending google, not attacking anyone.

A GPL-enforcement suit against VMware

Posted Mar 20, 2015 17:53 UTC (Fri) by Del- (guest, #72641) [Link] (3 responses)

You said Google was anti-GPLv3, and got called on it. Moreover, mud slinging v3 hurts GPL in general, and a smart man like you should realise that.

A GPL-enforcement suit against VMware

Posted Mar 20, 2015 20:18 UTC (Fri) by dlang (guest, #313) [Link] (2 responses)

I don't agree that it's inappropriate to criticize GPLv3 "because it hurts GPL". For the record, I think Linus has it right and GPLv3 has too many shades of "I am altering our deal, pray that I don't alter it further". But I wasn't arguing that the GPLv3 is bad, I was correcting the statement "google hates GPL"

I came away from the google training understanding that GPLv2 was perfectly acceptable, GPLv3 somewhat acceptable, but going back and looking up the license on the project that I remember being used as an example of Google paying big bucks for an exception to the license, it turns out that the project in question is AGPLv3, not GPLv3. so at this point it could be that I had a bad instructer in my session, or I just remembered it wrong.

People see the lack of GPL code in Android and think that it means that Google in anti-GPL and that is very much not the case, that's just the Android project.

A GPL-enforcement suit against VMware

Posted Mar 21, 2015 20:43 UTC (Sat) by Del- (guest, #72641) [Link] (1 responses)

>I don't agree that it's inappropriate to criticize GPLv3 "because it hurts GPL".

Now that wasn't quite what you did.

>For the record, I think Linus has it right

And I think you should let Linus talk for himself, you are hardly a mind reader. Personally I think both him and RMS let their ego come in the way. However, I have yet to see anybody criticize v3 without twisting facts, and you are no exception. It is counterproductive and it creates some noise that I am sick and tired of.

A GPL-enforcement suit against VMware

Posted Apr 1, 2015 4:54 UTC (Wed) by bronson (subscriber, #4806) [Link]

Care to add some content to your post? I particularly like your implication that it's humanly impossible to criticize v3. You don't actually believe that, do you?