I guess I'm just not so cavalier....

Posted Mar 25, 2010 19:58 UTC (Thu) by Simetrical (guest, #53439)
In reply to: I guess I'm just not so cavalier.... by robla
Parent article: Resetting PHP 6

If PHP hadn't existed, web hosts would be using something else instead. Probably something based on Unix permissions instead of things like open_basedir and max_timeout that try to enforce permissions or resource limits in userspace, thereby prohibiting perfectly sane things like shelling out to other programs.

If web hosts used something else, web apps would be written in something else. It's that simple. Wordpress and Drupal are web apps that happen to be written in PHP, not consequences of PHP's existence. I'd bet that they're written in PHP because that's how you reach the largest audience, because that's what webhosts use.

The Python GIL is a nonissue if you're running single-threaded code. Does PHP support multithreaded execution at *all*?

I guess I'm just not so cavalier....

Posted Mar 25, 2010 21:18 UTC (Thu) by foom (subscriber, #14868) [Link] (1 responses)

> The Python GIL is a nonissue if you're running single-threaded code.

Not really...Python doesn't properly support multiple distinct interpreters within a process -- you
can do it, but they aren't properly isolated from each-other. One important way they aren't isolated:
they all share the same GIL. So, you can't even properly run multiple single-threaded python
interpreters within a multithreaded process. It works, but only one thread can actually run at a time,
across all interpreters.

So of course that means you can't run python (efficiently) within a threaded apache.

I guess I'm just not so cavalier....

Posted Mar 25, 2010 22:31 UTC (Thu) by Simetrical (guest, #53439) [Link]

As far as I know, many/most PHP modules don't work at all with a threaded
Apache, and it's generally advised that mod_php users stick to prefork or
FastCGI. So this isn't a big advantage for PHP.

I guess I'm just not so cavalier....

Posted Mar 25, 2010 23:29 UTC (Thu) by JoeF (guest, #4486) [Link] (1 responses)

Does PHP support multithreaded execution at *all*?

Yes, it does.
But a large part of the third-party modules are not thread-safe, so unless you limit yourself to what you can run (and test the hell out of things), you are better off not running a multithreaded build of Apache.

I guess I'm just not so cavalier....

Posted Mar 26, 2010 13:51 UTC (Fri) by foom (subscriber, #14868) [Link]

I've kinda wondered how exaggerated this problem is. I mean, the default on windows is threaded -
- do most modules blow up by default on windows? That seems like a problem that their authors
would want to fix.