Long battle
Long battle
Posted Mar 23, 2025 9:02 UTC (Sun) by NYKevin (subscriber, #129325)In reply to: Long battle by pm215
Parent article: Julien Malka proposes method for detecting XZ-like backdoors
Some technical knowledge is required to snap all of the individual Lego bricks together, so I'm not suggesting that random non-tech companies are going to do this (they will buy a turnkey solution from somebody like IBM or Oracle, which will do something like this, but with more audit logs and misc. "compliance" features), but it is not nearly as hard as you seem to think. If you have a few competent engineers, it's mostly a question of political will and budgeting. That does not make it easy. It makes it feasible, under the right conditions, with managerial support. Ultimately, this is a business decision. If a company('s management) does not want reproducible builds, or is not willing to say "no" to a large number of employees in order to get reproducible builds, then it will not have reproducible builds.
***
Aside from that, while I appreciate that you are trying to deescalate the discussion, I really do not think the phrase "overengineered nonsense" is helpful, nor do I see any qualification in the original comment suggesting that it was restricted to smaller companies. I really wish we could be kinder to one another in discussions like this one.
Posted Mar 23, 2025 12:45 UTC (Sun)
by pm215 (subscriber, #98099)
[Link]
Long battle