LWN: Comments on "coLinux: Linux for Windows Without Rebooting (O'ReillyNet)"

coLinux: Linux for Windows Without Rebooting (O'ReillyNet)

Joshua999 — Fri, 15 Apr 2005 19:10:05 +0000

Dear Mr. O'Reilly,

I am from Switzerland, intending to use CoLinux.

My Question: Do I have to reboot? I don't think so,
BUT:

I got Emule Plus running (of which I am not in the least ashamed,
for i am standing for our Right On Culture in private purpose)
and i read that to install the correct network integration of Windows
to the Linux Emulation, one has got to:

CHANGE THE RUNING INTERNET CONNECTION BY ENABLING THE INTERNET CONNECTION
RELEASE FLAG, WHICH COULD LEAD TO THE ABRUPT LOSS OF THE RUNNING CONNECTION ?

Then i would loose all my Queue waiting positions of the precious downloads in eMule Plus, and this Sharing Tool is unlike Limewire or Shareazaa:
It needs at least 10 hours to get to an acceptable speed!!!

So: If the current net connection is endangered, I won't install CoLinux, but it would mean a great advantage to be able to experience Linux without
loosing your active internet connection!!!

Sincerely and thankfully yours for your time and answer

J.G.

coLinux: Linux for Windows Without Rebooting (O'ReillyNet)

gtoal — Sat, 03 Jul 2004 19:25:41 +0000

I've been using it for some weeks now and it is rock-solid stable. I set mine up to start as a service, and since I normally use WinXP for work purposes, I have frequently completely forgotten that coLinux is already started and running. I can connect to it any time I need linux access by using ssh. (This is on my laptop by the way)

It was very awkward to set up but these are early days for this code; it is remarkably solid already. I did have to switch to the gentoo distribution rather than SuSE which I use on my 'real' linux host, but actually that was quite fun too as the emerge/portage system of gentoo is a good innovation. Be warned however that it takes several days to fetch and compile your entire linux system so expect to require a fast link and a fast CPU.

Scores 8/10 for me - and will get 10/10 once it has an idiot-proof installer and can easily allow more versions of Linux to be installed by non-experts.

coLinux: Linux for Windows Without Rebooting (O'ReillyNet)

Cato — Mon, 03 May 2004 15:17:29 +0000

This sounds very useful as long as it doesn't render Windows unstable - should be far more Linux-like than Cygwin, and probably a lot faster and with fewer 'apps must be GPLed' issues.