|
|
Log in / Subscribe / Register

Security people are so weird…

Security people are so weird…

Posted Oct 31, 2024 7:00 UTC (Thu) by zdzichu (subscriber, #17118)
In reply to: Security people are so weird… by mirabilos
Parent article: Security quotes of the week

> The main idea here is that worrying about "silly" AI uses, like making low-quality content, is less important than focusing on serious, harmful uses of AI, like in policing, healthcare, security, and customer service. These areas are where AI companies make the most money, attracting huge investments. The writer argues that most investment in AI is not for fun or harmless uses but for high-stakes applications that AI is actually not very good at and which can cause harm. Therefore, to be an effective critic of AI, people should pay attention to these serious uses, even if they’re less eye-catching, because challenging them impacts companies financially.

I've asked one of the LLMs to summarize the excerpt for a non-native speaker to understand. Did it succeed?


to post comments

Security people are so weird…

Posted Oct 31, 2024 11:50 UTC (Thu) by excors (subscriber, #95769) [Link] (3 responses)

> Did it succeed?

Not entirely, because it falsely implies "silly" is a direct quote, and the original excerpt doesn't imply the "AI slop" is silly at all. The majority of the article's focus is on that low-quality generated content, as something that "still has cultural significance and is worth considering" and that Facebook scammers use to exploit Thatcher's atomisation of society etc, so the article is taking it quite seriously.

Security people are so weird…

Posted Nov 11, 2024 13:00 UTC (Mon) by lbt (subscriber, #29672) [Link] (2 responses)

Interestingly I (an 'experienced' native British english writer) often use quotes to suggest that I'm paraphrasing or generalising a concept; that maybe it shouldn't be taken literally. In the previous sentence I'm using 'experienced' to refer to my age in a roundabout way; in this one I'm quoting it directly.

I read ' "silly" ' to mean : not literally silly but, you know, not exactly mission critical.

Security people are so weird…

Posted Nov 11, 2024 13:29 UTC (Mon) by excors (subscriber, #95769) [Link] (1 responses)

I think that's a form of scare quotes, which can be valid, but the context is important. In your example there's no indication of any source that "experienced" might be a direct quote from, so it's clear that it probably means "some hypothetical people could say I'm experienced, though that's not exactly what I mean so I'm going to distance myself from it with punctuation". But in the context of summarising an article, there is a very obvious source for direct quotes (i.e. the article itself), so I think a reasonable reader would interpret the quotation marks as almost certainly being a direct quote. Since that interpretation is incorrect, the so-called "writer" should have avoided using such misleading punctuation here. And being clear and unambiguous is even more important when it's explicitly "for a non-native speaker to understand".

Security people are so weird…

Posted Nov 11, 2024 15:38 UTC (Mon) by Wol (subscriber, #4433) [Link]

Hmm ... I think you're missing that the post EXPLICTLY said that the quote was generated by an AI. (Okay, it took me a while to work out exactly what the post was saying, but I do think it is pretty clear and unambiguous - once you step back and think about it!)

As a native English speaker, " "silly" like ..." (which is what the AI generated) seems very clearly to me to be calling "low-quality content" "silly".

> And being clear and unambiguous is even more important when it's explicitly "for a non-native speaker to understand".

You mean like trying to write American clearly for an English speaker? You're on to a losing battle there! "The English and Americans are two nations divided by a common language".

Cheers,
Wol

Security people are so weird…

Posted Oct 31, 2024 15:51 UTC (Thu) by mirabilos (subscriber, #84359) [Link]

That is most unhelpful. I refuse to poison my mind with LLM sludge.


Copyright © 2026, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds