Use cases
Use cases
Posted Aug 12, 2024 12:05 UTC (Mon) by mb (subscriber, #50428)In reply to: Use cases by Wol
Parent article: Distinguishing Debian testing from unstable
Luca's view is valid.
Sid can be used as if it were its own rolling release.
In fact, I have been using it for the last two decades as such.
And no, it does not break all the time. Only occasionally. :)
But it is also valid to see Sid as just a precursor place for the packages that will eventually end up in testing without a modification.
The difference in thinking is the upgrade path thinking (Luca) versus the package migration path thinking (mine; and apparently also Debian's).
These paths are orthogonal.
If Debian decides to mark os-release in Sid with the testing codename, that is perfectly valid in the package migration path world view.
The person who wants to change this established policy is responsible for providing good real world examples showing why the change improves things.
So far I didn't see anything that would convince me. Pointing to the presence of a sid workaround in a random shell script does not prove that sid is wrong. The shell script can also be wrong to use the codename in the first place.
It is needed to explain to people why the script can't do it in another way instead of pointing to random github searches that carry not a single bit of information to resolve the issue. (just to mention one ridiculous example).
