Never break userspace [LWN.net]

Never break userspace

Posted Feb 16, 2024 19:41 UTC (Fri) by mb (subscriber, #50428)
In reply to: Never break userspace by bluca
Parent article: A turning point for CVE numbers

>Citation needed

Even syscalls have been removed in the past, breaking applications.
BUT these applications always were very limited in count and usually part of the OS itself.

Citation: Look at the sources.

There has never been a thing like a general stability guarantee.
It always has been a matter of common sense.
If a change only breaks udev or systemd and nothing else, it might make sense to do it.

to post comments

Never break userspace

Posted Feb 16, 2024 20:07 UTC (Fri) by bluca (subscriber, #118303) [Link]

Excellent, you have now demonstrated that my original post, claiming that there is no such thing as 'kernel never breaks userspace', was indeed correct, and thus 'just update to the latest' cannot be suggested as a solution to security issues since public interfaces will be broken left and right with no regard for backward compatibility. Congrats!

> If a change only breaks udev or systemd and nothing else, it might make sense to do it.

I beg to differ