|
|
Log in / Subscribe / Register

Security quote of the week

Amazon can do this because the Alexa's operating system sits behind a cryptographic lock, and any tool that bypasses that lock is a felony under Section 1201 of the DMCA, punishable by a 5-year prison sentence and a $500,000 fine. That means that it's literally a crime to provide a rival OS that lets users retain functionality that Amazon no longer supports.

This is the proverbial gun on the mantelpiece, a moral hazard and invitation to mischief that tempts Amazon executives to run a bait-and-switch con where they sell you a gadget with five features and then remotely kill-switch two of them. This is prime directive of the Darth Vader MBA: "I am altering the deal. Pray I don't alter it any further."

— Cory Doctorow on Amazon killing Alexa integration with IFTTT

to post comments

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 2, 2023 14:01 UTC (Thu) by Cyberax (✭ supporter ✭, #52523) [Link] (28 responses)

> Amazon can do this because the Alexa's operating system sits behind a cryptographic lock, and any tool that bypasses that lock is a felony under Section 1201 of the DMCA, punishable by a 5-year prison sentence and a $500,000 fine.

Doctorow is, as usually, full of shit. It's not illegal to bypass cryptographic locks. It's illegal to do that to access copyrighted materials without a license. The law literally says this: "to prevent unauthorized access to copyrighted works".

It's perfectly legal to break crypto locks to install your own OS on a device.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 2, 2023 15:27 UTC (Thu) by pizza (subscriber, #46) [Link] (8 responses)

> It's perfectly legal to break crypto locks to install your own OS on a device.

Not if that same tool allows you to *read* out what's already in there. Because it's the same lock being broken either way.

Not only is breaking the lock illegal, distribution of (or even discussion about how to create) the tool that can break the lock is also illegal under the DMCA.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 2, 2023 15:59 UTC (Thu) by Cyberax (✭ supporter ✭, #52523) [Link] (7 responses)

> Not if that same tool allows you to *read* out what's already in there. Because it's the same lock being broken either way.

If you are installing a new OS, then you don't read stuff. And since we're talking about _criminal_ penalties, the burden of proof is on the state.

There's nothing inside Alexa devices, they are just dumb speakers with microphones and WiFi modules. And even better, voice assistants are specifically listed in the exemptions to the DMCA for jailbreaking.

> Not only is breaking the lock illegal, distribution of (or even discussion about how to create) the tool that can break the lock is also illegal under the DMCA.

Nope. It's only illegal if done for the purpose of enabling piracy.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 2, 2023 16:13 UTC (Thu) by pizza (subscriber, #46) [Link] (4 responses)

> If you are installing a new OS, then you don't read stuff. And since we're talking about _criminal_ penalties, the burden of proof is on the state.

....You're still breaking the lock protecting copyrighted material.

And sure, while the burden of proof is on the state, ask Dmitry Sklyarov about how much ultimately being found not guilty ultimately cost him.

> It's only illegal if done for the purpose of enabling piracy.

Please explain how does breaking the lock does not "enable piracy"

Meanwhile:

https://www.eff.org/pages/unintended-consequences-fifteen...

This is a decade old and provides literally dozens of counterexamples to your farcical assertion.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 2, 2023 16:24 UTC (Thu) by Cyberax (✭ supporter ✭, #52523) [Link] (3 responses)

> ....You're still breaking the lock protecting copyrighted material.

And this is not illegal in itself, unlike some one-trick-pony authors want to tell you. And let me repeat, voice assistant jailbreaking is specifically exempted.

> And sure, while the burden of proof is on the state, ask Dmitry Sklyarov about how much ultimately being found not guilty ultimately cost him.

That happens with new laws and regulations. And these days, security research is also specifically exempted from the DMCA restrictions.

> This is a decade old and provides literally dozens of counterexamples to your farcical assertion.

This is the reason why I stopped donating to FSS and EFF. They're just fearmongering. Their list is mostly pre-2010, and it mostly lists overeager companies using DMCA to bully people, rather than actual convictions.

Reality is, DMCA is now mostly a settled law, with a good number of cases. And nobody is coming for you if you jailbreak your iPhone or Alexa.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 2, 2023 16:53 UTC (Thu) by pizza (subscriber, #46) [Link] (2 responses)

> Reality is, DMCA is now mostly a settled law, with a good number of cases. And nobody is coming for you if you jailbreak your iPhone or Alexa.

Ah, so Apple is "nobody", got it.

(My current employer has been fighting Apple for more than two years. We've won at every step so far, but it's still been a huge drain on time, energy, and money. So, respectfully, you don't know as much as you think you do.)

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 2, 2023 17:01 UTC (Thu) by Cyberax (✭ supporter ✭, #52523) [Link] (1 responses)

> Ah, so Apple is "nobody", got it.

Apple is not DMCA-ing people who jailbreak their phones. I have no idea what your employer's problem with Apple is.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 3, 2023 14:14 UTC (Fri) by pizza (subscriber, #46) [Link]

> Apple is not DMCA-ing people who jailbreak their phones. I have no idea what your employer's problem with Apple is.

You're right in that Apple doesn't care about _individuals_ that jailbreak their own equipment. They'll just blacklist the device, having already made a nice profit on the hardware sale, and move on. That said, Apple has been _extremely_ litigious when it comes to folks creating or providing *tools* that can be used to jailbreak phones or otherwise bypass Apple's security features.

My employer doesn't produce/create jailbreaking (etc) tools, but our offerings can be used to help create those tools. Apple sued, lost in the lower court, appealed, and was effectively benchslapped there. They're currently trying for an en-banc appeal, presumably out of spite at this point.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 2, 2023 17:00 UTC (Thu) by pizza (subscriber, #46) [Link] (1 responses)

> There's nothing inside Alexa devices, they are just dumb speakers with microphones and WiFi modules. And even better, voice assistants are specifically listed in the exemptions to the DMCA for jailbreaking.

Amazon doesn't GAF about Alexa specifically (after all, the secret sauce is in the cloud and the lock-in happens no matter what client device you use), but what they _do_ care about is the "protected audio path" for their streaming music service. This is what the lock is actually protecting. (that and the business model that expects profit from these services to make up the loss they're taking on the actual hardware...)

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 2, 2023 17:08 UTC (Thu) by Cyberax (✭ supporter ✭, #52523) [Link]

> what they _do_ care about is the "protected audio path" for their streaming music service.

There is no "protected audio path". They don't care about it. You can run their music player or the audiobook reader in a browser, with a paper-thin DRM.

You also can literally run Alexa on an RPi, with all the functionality available, including playing audiobooks. There's even an official guide for it: https://developer.amazon.com/en-US/docs/alexa/avs-device-...

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 2, 2023 16:16 UTC (Thu) by excors (subscriber, #95769) [Link] (18 responses)

Also, I believe this is nothing to do with "the Alexa's operating system" being locked down. Partly because Alexa doesn't have an operating system - it's basically an SDK that runs on many different OSes, on many devices, from many vendors, with many different security configurations. (You can run it on a Raspberry Pi if you want: https://developer.amazon.com/en-US/docs/alexa/avs-device-...)

But mainly because the IFTTT functionality is not on the device. It's part of the Alexa cloud services, built and maintained by Amazon, running on Amazon's servers. The DMCA is not what's stopping you modifying that functionality.

Doctorow says "This is a big deal: once a customer learns how to de-Amazon their Alexa, Amazon might never recapture that customer". But that's not a big deal, because the "Alexa" (I assume he means Echo) hardware is not very interesting. It's just a Linux computer with a speaker and microphone array. The interesting part of Alexa is Amazon's cloud services, plus all the third-party cloud services that are integrated with it. If you de-Amazon your device, there will be basically nothing left. Amazon is not worried about you doing that.

If (in his example) Walmart wants to build "an alternative Alexa software stack", they can simply buy an off-the-shelf smart speaker design from some Chinese manufacturer, then write their own device software that connects to their own cloud software. The devices are like $30 each, so there's little vendor lock-in and no need to reuse a customer's existing Amazon hardware. (The only problem Walmart would have is that it would likely cost billions of dollars to build that software to a competitive level. That's not because of any legal restrictions, it's just a lot of code to write.)

It does sound rather like Doctorow has no idea how any of this technology works.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 4, 2023 20:50 UTC (Sat) by rra (subscriber, #99804) [Link] (17 responses)

> It does sound rather like Doctorow has no idea how any of this technology works.

Doctorow has no idea how most of the things he writes about works. He is an excellent example of the phenomenon of "when he writes about things I know something about, what he writes is mostly nonsense, but surely his writing on other topics must be more accurate!"

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 4, 2023 21:41 UTC (Sat) by Wol (subscriber, #4433) [Link]

Or is he like most of us (I'm sure some people here will say I'm describing myself :-) where - because we are actually knowledgeable on a few subjects - we like to spout on subjects we know nothing about :-)

Cheers,
Wol

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 5, 2023 22:48 UTC (Sun) by pizza (subscriber, #46) [Link] (15 responses)

> Doctorow has no idea how most of the things he writes about works.

Be that as it may, is Doctorow actually *wrong* in what he's saying?

Does DRM (enforced under penalty of ruinously expensive lawsuits, even if you ultimately win) not prevent folks from repairing hardware they've purchased? Do cloud-based services not attempt to simultaneously lock users in and also remove functionality (if not shut down entirely) with little notice and no actual recourse? Have these things not moved from unusual to the norm?

This kind of BS is why the successful legal battles against DRM are being waged by *farmers* rather than the technical community, who keep displaying a self-defeating tendency to bicker amongst themselves while their opponents win with little effort.

Getting these problems to move from being something that happens to "someone else who probably deserved it" or "it's just some geeks arguing about theoretical problems" to "this happened to someone I know" and "this could happen to me next!" is _hard_ and Doctorow is able to reach a _far_ greater general audience than the technical community on its own. The folks that he reaches don't understand the technical nuances involved -- nor does it actually matter; what they *do* care about is that someone else can lock them out of stuff they are increasingly forced to rely upon.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 6, 2023 3:18 UTC (Mon) by rra (subscriber, #99804) [Link]

Sure, that's the whole idea. Doctorow says things that aren't precisely true or correct, but the vibes are right. He says stuff that isn't precisely what's going on, but gesture at things that indeed are worth being upset about if you're generally on Doctorow's side politically. He may not be telling the precise truth and leaving out a bunch of details, but surely we can all agree that he's trying to highlight real problems in the world, right?

So, you know, the same thing that the FBI does when they try to convince Congress to ban encryption because of the children, except we like Doctorow's politics and we don't like the FBI's politics, so the theory is that Doctorow, if listened to, would result in better public policy because he has the right vibes, whereas the FBI have the wrong vibes. So the FBI are lying but Doctorow is a truth-teller who simplifies things for a mass audience.

Doctorow is a political activist who says stuff to create emotional reactions and try to get people to act in the direction he wants them to act, with truth being secondary to that goal. This is quite effective! That's why political activists of all political stripes do it a lot.

Whether it bothers you depends on where you personally would draw the line between simplifying things for a mass audience and saying things that are not really true to create more of a reaction for a mass audience. I personally am a complexity guy. I don't like people who simplify in ways that aren't true and I think some types of simplifying are lying. But that's also why I'm a bad political activist.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 6, 2023 4:13 UTC (Mon) by Cyberax (✭ supporter ✭, #52523) [Link] (13 responses)

> Be that as it may, is Doctorow actually *wrong* in what he's saying?

Yes. Pretty much none of his predictions came true. He predicted a DRM/DMCA gulag where The Microsoft (which has replaced the government) controls every aspect of your life to protect The Precious Content, for which you have to pay with your arms and legs, with death penalty for infringement. And I'm not really exaggerating here.

Instead, now we can access more content than it's possible to ever consume for $10 a month, if that. DRM is at the "nagware" level. So it is slightly more annoying to remove the DRM, compared to buying content legally. And music is sold without any DRM whatsoever. General purpose computing is easy and accessible, so you can host a full website on a $3 microcontroller.

> Does DRM (enforced under penalty of ruinously expensive lawsuits, even if you ultimately win) not prevent folks from repairing hardware they've purchased?

It does not.

> Do cloud-based services not attempt to simultaneously lock users in and also remove functionality (if not shut down entirely) with little notice and no actual recourse? Have these things not moved from unusual to the norm?

What cloud-based services have to do with DRM?

> This kind of BS is why the successful legal battles against DRM are being waged by *farmers*

The whole "farmers forced to restore heritage tractors because all new tractors are locked down" story is just another load of BS.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 6, 2023 13:04 UTC (Mon) by Wol (subscriber, #4433) [Link] (3 responses)

> Instead, now we can access more content than it's possible to ever consume for $10 a month, if that. DRM is at the "nagware" level. So it is slightly more annoying to remove the DRM, compared to buying content legally. And music is sold without any DRM whatsoever. General purpose computing is easy and accessible, so you can host a full website on a $3 microcontroller.

So I'm now forced to pay $10/month for a seat at an "all you can eat" restaurant, when before I was probably paying $5/yr for far more than I wanted ... ???

I'm sick to the back teeth of being bombarded with ads saying "£15/month for our best mobile phone deal!!!" when I'm currently paying £5 and wasting nearly all of it. Yep, for SOME people it may be good value, but forcing EVERYone to pay it? NO THANKS!

Cheers,
Wol

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 6, 2023 14:24 UTC (Mon) by Cyberax (✭ supporter ✭, #52523) [Link] (2 responses)

Nobody is forcing you to consume the content. I don't have any subscriptions anymore, because I'm not really interested in them.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 6, 2023 14:31 UTC (Mon) by Wol (subscriber, #4433) [Link] (1 responses)

Yes I know I'm not being FORCED. But for example it's getting harder and harder to buy music without having to subscribe to a streaming service.

That's the problem - if I'm *mostly* uninterested, getting and paying for what I want is getting much harder. If I want to listen to a classical concert once in a while - £10 a CD? - it's difficult to buy and play CDs any more, the streaming services really aren't geared to minority music of any sort, and why should I pay a subscription that costs far more than buying the occasional CD?

Cheers,
Wol

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 6, 2023 16:01 UTC (Mon) by excors (subscriber, #95769) [Link]

If you don't want CDs or vinyl, you can download DRM-free MP3/AAC from iTunes, Amazon, Bandcamp, Qobuz, etc. For classical music in particular there's Presto Music, eClassical, labels like Hyperion Records, etc (all offering 96kHz 24-bit FLAC, i.e. better than CD quality). It doesn't seem there's really a lack of options nowadays.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 6, 2023 23:12 UTC (Mon) by pizza (subscriber, #46) [Link] (6 responses)

> He predicted a DRM/DMCA gulag where The Microsoft (which has replaced the government) controls every aspect of your life to protect The Precious Content,

Yeah, he was wrong. Because it's Google and Amazon (along with the RIAA+MPAA) controlling things, not Microsoft (who actually shut down their services, leaving lots of folks in the lurch).

> Instead, now we can access more content than it's possible to ever consume for $10 a month,

...As long as you keep paying, forever.. Oh, and use _only_ their applications (which includes webapps that require third-party browser-level DRM binaries to be running).

(Or unless you get your account revoked due to something completely unrelated. Or they decide to shut down their service enttirely. Or, or, or... And _PLEASE_ don't try to argue that these things don't happen; examples are legion)

> The whole "farmers forced to restore heritage tractors because all new tractors are locked down" story is just another load of BS.

Nobody actually cares about "heritage" tractors except equipment fetishists. However, the price of older (pre-emission, ie >10-year-old) tractors has gone way, way up, in no small part because they are mechanically far simpler and be field-repairable without having to take things to the dealer. How do I know this? Because (1) I have been looking to buy a tractor for a while now, and (2) the farmers that are increasingly vocal about this crap are my literal *neighbours*.

"The right to repair" is one of the very few areas of agreement my (very) conservative rural community has with "the libs", who are otherwise what's wrong with everything in society/country/world.

So, to apply your Doctorow logic to you, if you're this wrong about something I actually do know about, why should I put stock in anything else you have to say?

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 7, 2023 17:14 UTC (Tue) by Cyberax (✭ supporter ✭, #52523) [Link] (5 responses)

> Yeah, he was wrong. Because it's Google and Amazon (along with the RIAA+MPAA) controlling things

Google barely produces their own content. And pretty much the only content they resell is on YouTube. Some of it is DRM-ed, but they don't particularly care to make it resilient. Amazon is in a similar position, although they do produce their own content (via Prime Video). And none of them is interested in controlling the general-purpose compute.

This is not at all surprising. The movie and music market is tiny, the total box office for the US and Canada is less than $10B a year. The estimated capitalization of Hollywood companies is around $100B. Music labels are even smaller, they have an estimated $10B capitalization.

So these industries are certainly significant, but not so much as to warp the whole legal system to serve their needs.

> ...As long as you keep paying, forever.. Oh, and use _only_ their applications (which includes webapps that require third-party browser-level DRM binaries to be running).

The app limitation is the worst one, I agree. But I believe that it'll eventually be fixed, like it happened in other areas. An open solution shared across providers will be better for everyone in the long run. It'll probably happen once the content market settles a bit.

There'll be something like a standard for streaming video, with several vendors producing competing player applications.

> However, the price of older (pre-emission, ie >10-year-old) tractors has gone way, way up, in no small part because they are mechanically far simpler and be field-repairable without having to take things to the dealer.

The price of used tractors spiked for the same reason the price of used cars spiked: supply chain disruption and shortages, plus effects of strikes in 2021. Modern tractors are far less likely to break, like modern cars versus cars in 80-s. And most of the breakages are purely mechanical, and can be repaired by the owner.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 9, 2023 15:50 UTC (Thu) by pizza (subscriber, #46) [Link] (3 responses)

> Google barely produces their own content

They do, however, sell a *lot* of other people's content, and also provide DRM services that many, many content providers rely upon.

> And none of them is interested in controlling the general-purpose compute.

Because they're content to let general-purpose computing wither and die on the vine, in favor of a locked-down appliance-centric model that they _do_ control.

> There'll be something like a standard for streaming video, with several vendors producing competing player applications.

On what do you base this naive fantasy? Literally every single trend in the video space points in the opposite direction. It's going to take national legislation (or more likely, new international treaties) to change this.

> The price of used tractors spiked for the same reason the price of used cars spiked: supply chain disruption and shortages, plus effects of strikes in 2021. Modern tractors are far less likely to break, like modern cars versus cars in 80-s. And most of the breakages are purely mechanical, and can be repaired by the owner.

Supply chain disruptions affected *everything*, but pre-emissions [1] equipment on the used market remains _more_ expensive than more modern equipment (of the same general performance class, anyway).

So who am I to believe, you or my own lying eyes?

(Again, right to repair is literally a *local* issue for me [2], with both sides being quite vocal politically.)

[1] Ie the excuse that Deere uses for DRM-restricting parts.
[2] Over 50% of the land in my county is actively farmland, and to get to the nearest town I have to drive past about 30km of farms. The majority of the rest is "tree farms", with residential and various preserves bringing up the rear)

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 9, 2023 16:33 UTC (Thu) by farnz (subscriber, #17727) [Link]

Pre-emissions diesel engines are both less likely to break down (every engine fault on my diesel car in the last 100,000 miles has been the emissions control equipment malfunctioning, and my previous two diesel cars - pre-emissions - got to 200,000 miles before I had an engine fault), and are much easier to repair in the field than newer engines.

Even if you took away the DRM, I'd still expect farmers to pay a premium for pre-emissions diesels over more modern ones, precisely because of that "ease of repairs in the field" issue; given the cost to farmers of a tractor failure at the wrong moment, they are going to put a price premium on pre-emissions equipment even without John Deere playing the DRM games they're playing.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 9, 2023 17:54 UTC (Thu) by Cyberax (✭ supporter ✭, #52523) [Link] (1 responses)

> They do, however, sell a *lot* of other people's content, and also provide DRM services that many, many content providers rely upon.

Sure. But their DRM is about as strong as a wet paper tissue. It's trivial to work around it.

> Because they're content to let general-purpose computing wither and die on the vine, in favor of a locked-down appliance-centric model that they _do_ control.

The death of general-purpose computing has been greatly exaggerated many times. I remember when Steve Jobs (?) said that basically nobody needs anything but an iPad.

> On what do you base this naive fantasy? Literally every single trend in the video space points in the opposite direction. It's going to take national legislation (or more likely, new international treaties) to change this.

Yes, and this is expected. The video streaming industry is in the "proliferation" stage. It happens in any young industry, you initially get a number of small players. Then they start consolidating and you get several large, dominant players. At this point, smaller players either get gobbled up and die (and you're left with an oligopoly), or they band together and create standards that allow them to collaborate and interoperate.

Then these standards eventually get adopted by everyone in the industry.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 10, 2023 3:54 UTC (Fri) by pizza (subscriber, #46) [Link]

> Sure. But their DRM is about as strong as a wet paper tissue. It's trivial to work around it.

Unfortunately, the relative strength of DRM does not factor into the illegality of bypassing it.

> The death of general-purpose computing has been greatly exaggerated many times. I remember when Steve Jobs (?) said that basically nobody needs anything but an iPad.

Twenty years ago nearly everything sold was general purpose, and not locked down. Today the overwhelming majority of computing systems sold are locked down [1] with its users at the complete mercy of what its vendors allow. Case in point, Apple themselves. These days they're mostly a phone company that happens to sell some computers on the side.

> At this point, smaller players either get gobbled up and die (and you're left with an oligopoly), or they band together and create standards that allow them to collaborate and interoperate.

Again, all available evidence points to the former happening -- Just last week Disney purchased Hulu, for example. Even beyond that, what little "interoperation" that's existed has been deliberately walked back (if not blocked outright) to ensure would-be aggregators (aka the writers of the apps/frontends that users would use) are unable to data mine and insert their own advertising in front of this content.

[1] In 2022, about 1.9 billion Android+iOS devices were sold, vs about 310 million PCs+Macs.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 14, 2023 14:46 UTC (Tue) by mathstuf (subscriber, #69389) [Link]

> Modern tractors are far less likely to break, like modern cars versus cars in 80-s. And most of the breakages are purely mechanical, and can be repaired by the owner.

What used to be a "use a hammer to fix (or just ignore it)" dent repair can now be a "replace the entire bumper because you severed a wire in the sensor array" repair. This puts minor accidents within "totaled" range much more easily.

Of course, I'm also seeing that given depreciation rates and rising repair costs, totalling older cars for fender benders is also not uncommon.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 14, 2023 14:39 UTC (Tue) by mathstuf (subscriber, #69389) [Link] (1 responses)

> Instead, now we can access more content than it's possible to ever consume for $10 a month, if that. DRM is at the "nagware" level. So it is slightly more annoying to remove the DRM, compared to buying content legally. And music is sold without any DRM whatsoever.

Please tell me where I can purchase durable ways of watching things like the Wheel of Time series so that I can watch it on my own terms (including without Internet). How about Squid Games? We used to get discs pressed and sold so that those without the subscription (such as HBO series) could enjoy them. Or enjoy them when they're not scheduled conveniently (e.g., Law & Order). Now one has to pony up a fee for every viewing (that doesn't fit within a time window).

> General purpose computing is easy and accessible, so you can host a full website on a $3 microcontroller.

"General purpose computing" can't consume the content you're referring to. Only those blessed with app support can.

Security quote of the week

Posted Nov 14, 2023 22:19 UTC (Tue) by Cyberax (✭ supporter ✭, #52523) [Link]

> How about Squid Games?

Create a Netflix subscription, download it for offline viewing in their webapp (should work on Linux), watch it, cancel the subscription.

I believe, it would work out to something like $1 per episode. There are also "Netflix Downloader" applications that just break the DRM.

> Now one has to pony up a fee for every viewing (that doesn't fit within a time window).

For every _month_ of viewing. I don't consider this to be too onerous.

> "General purpose computing" can't consume the content you're referring to. Only those blessed with app support can.

Basically, you need anything that can run Chrome or Firefox. ESP32 is not quite up to it, true.


Copyright © 2023, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds