Free software and fiduciary duty
Free software and fiduciary duty
Posted Mar 6, 2023 11:28 UTC (Mon) by james (guest, #1325)In reply to: Free software and fiduciary duty by nybble41
Parent article: Free software and fiduciary duty
Lord Justice Birss, in the Court of Appeal in London, wrote:
There was no dispute that the cryptocurrency in issue was property...nybble41 asked:
Why wasn't this disputed?The case was between "Tulip Trading Limited, a company associated with Dr Craig Wright" and sixteen defendants, including Bitcoin Association for BSV and the developers who "control and run the four relevant bitcoin networks".
Which of them is going to argue that Bitcoin isn't property?
English civil law (IANAL) is adversarial, hence the Lord Justice's careful wording — "there was no dispute". English courts won't normally rule on questions that aren't before them. A judge might take the point if a case was clearly based on an incorrect premise, but that isn't the case here — it at least arguably passes the duck test for property. It's not that far from concepts such as copyrights, futures and derivatives¹.
As for the fork question, the judge wrote:
One aspect of the defendants' case is that if such a patch was added to the bitcoin network source code at the relevant GitHub database, then the miners might not accept it and a fork would or may occur, but the likelihood of that happening is an aspect of the dispute on decentralisaton which cannot be resolved without a trialpresumably because the court would need to hear evidence on it.
¹ "... trading in pork futures—in pork that doesn’t exist yet—led to the building of the warehouse to store it in until it does..." — Terry Pratchett, Men at Arms, a satirical fantasy novel.
