|
|
Log in / Subscribe / Register

Beingessner: Rust's Unsafe Pointer Types Need An Overhaul

Beingessner: Rust's Unsafe Pointer Types Need An Overhaul

Posted Mar 22, 2022 18:00 UTC (Tue) by njs (subscriber, #40338)
In reply to: Beingessner: Rust's Unsafe Pointer Types Need An Overhaul by wtarreau
Parent article: Beingessner: Rust's Unsafe Pointer Types Need An Overhaul

> Seems like the language is starting to face the real world of computers, in which absolutely nothing distinguishes a pointer from an integer, both are used and stored interchangeably in registers, it's only how they are _used_ that makes us consider one is arbitrarily a pointer or an integer.

I think it's exactly the opposite: at the language level, C/C++/unsafe Rust all say that you're allowed to convert back and forth between integers and pointers, because the language designers had the same intuition you did – that's how the machine actually works, so it'll be fine.

But there are two problems:

- that's not actually how all machines work (like this exotic CHERI thing, or old-school segmented architectures)

- more importantly, even on common ISAs like x86 and ARM, it turns out that if you want a decent compiler, your front end needs to target a higher-level virtual machine where pointers *aren't* just integers. Of course they'll eventually get lowered to integers, but if you do that too early then it destroys your ability to do optimizations. So the status quo right now is that all compilers *actually* treat integers and pointers as fundamentally different, and they do it using a bunch of ad hoc heuristics that were never written down and the compiler engineers have been gradually realizing are actually incoherent and busted, even if they *mostly* work in practice.

So the problem is: how do we change the language and the compiler so that the code is efficient *and* the compiler rigorously implements the language semantics *and* the language semantics are understandable without a phd. And this means the language semantics need to treat pointers and integers as fundamentally different, while still giving enough tools to do all the weird pointer tricks you need in real systems.


to post comments


Copyright © 2026, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds