|
|
Log in / Subscribe / Register

OSI: Court affirms it's false advertising to claim software is Open Source when it’s not

OSI: Court affirms it's false advertising to claim software is Open Source when it’s not

Posted Mar 19, 2022 3:43 UTC (Sat) by KJ7RRV (subscriber, #153595)
In reply to: OSI: Court affirms it's false advertising to claim software is Open Source when it’s not by fredrik
Parent article: OSI: Court affirms it's false advertising to claim software is Open Source when it’s not

Okay, thank you. So it would take another case to determine what the default meaning of "free software" is?


to post comments

OSI: Court affirms it's false advertising to claim software is Open Source when it’s not

Posted Mar 20, 2022 19:32 UTC (Sun) by NYKevin (subscriber, #129325) [Link] (5 responses)

That's simply not how false advertising works. There is no "default meaning" of anything. It's always a case-by-case totality-of-the-circumstances test. The court is not trying to determine some sort of Platonic ideal of what the ad means, they're trying to figure out if consumers would be confused or misled. But such confusion always depends on an elaborate constellation of factors, and cannot be firmly tied down to the meaning of one word or phrase in isolation.

For example, if you display the word "free" right next to a purchase price, consumers might find that hard to understand, but they're (probably) not going to walk away thinking that the price is $0.

Libre vs gratis in advertising

Posted Mar 21, 2022 1:27 UTC (Mon) by KJ7RRV (subscriber, #153595) [Link] (4 responses)

Okay, that makes sense. So an ad that says "Free Software Downloads - $10/program" is probably okay, because "free" can only mean libre there, but "Free Software Downloads" on its own is not (if you actually have to pay), because it could be interpreted as gratis? (I'm just curious, if I ever sell copies of free software I'll make sure I label it clearly, and I know any answer will not be legal advice)

Also, is "Free Software Downloads" false advertising if the software is gratis but not libre (e.g. any of the proprietary "free" apps in app stores)?

Libre vs gratis in advertising

Posted Mar 21, 2022 5:12 UTC (Mon) by mathstuf (subscriber, #69389) [Link]

One could also argue that the *download* is free (a la "free delivery").

Libre vs gratis in advertising

Posted Mar 21, 2022 8:38 UTC (Mon) by anselm (subscriber, #2796) [Link] (1 responses)

So an ad that says "Free Software Downloads - $10/program" is probably okay, because "free" can only mean libre there, but "Free Software Downloads" on its own is not (if you actually have to pay), because it could be interpreted as gratis?

That's what hyphens are for. “Free-Software Downloads” implies that we're talking about downloads of “free software” (a term of art), not software downloads that are free (of charge?).

Libre vs gratis in advertising

Posted Mar 21, 2022 19:17 UTC (Mon) by KJ7RRV (subscriber, #153595) [Link]

I didn't think of the word "downloads" affecting it like that; if a company labels a program as "Free" does it have to be libre, gratis, or both?

Libre vs gratis in advertising

Posted Mar 21, 2022 16:22 UTC (Mon) by rgmoore (✭ supporter ✭, #75) [Link]

I think the key thing is that "free" is a term likely to lead to confusion, since it has two completely different meanings. If you don't specify which meaning you intend, people might legitimately be confused. But this isn't inevitable. If you make sure the discussion is in context, you can make sure people will understand the meaning you intend. If you talk about "free software" in a discussion of licenses and say it meets FSF and DFS guidelines, people will assume you're talking about freedom. If you talk about "free software" but say there will be a charge for advanced features, people will assume you're talking about price.

In this case, you might be able to clarify with some footnotes. If you say something like "Free1 and Open Source2 Software" with the footnotes pointing to FSF and OSI documents talking about your licensing, the meaning would be clear. This is exactly why so many ads that talk about technical stuff include footnotes; they want to make sure nobody can accuse them of being misleading.


Copyright © 2026, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds