|
|
Log in / Subscribe / Register

GCC drops its copyright-assignment requirement

GCC drops its copyright-assignment requirement

Posted Jun 9, 2021 23:38 UTC (Wed) by Wol (subscriber, #4433)
In reply to: GCC drops its copyright-assignment requirement by matthias
Parent article: GCC drops its copyright-assignment requirement

> No, Alice granted GPL2+ to Bob. And once Bob distributes according to GPL3 terms, the GPL3 specifies that Alice grants a GPL3 license to Carol. The license granted to Carol is thus not identical to the license granted to Bob. That is fine according to copyright law. Clearly I can create a license foo (GPL2+) that states every third person who will receive the code will get a license bar (GPL3).

WORDS MATTER! Where in the GPL does it say that Alice GRANTS a licence TO Carol? It says that Carol GETS a licence FROM Alice. That's not the same thing at all! And seeing as the only licence Alice has granted is GPL2+, that is the licence Carol gets. For her to get anything else, she must have received that licence from Bob, which the GPL explicitly says DOES NOT HAPPEN.

Plus, how come Bob has not forwarded to Carol the right he had to choose ANY licence allowed by GPL2+? The GPL itself says that that is what the GPL seeks to enforce. And if the GPL explicitly states its intent, then a Judge is likely to say that is a requirement, pre-amble or no.

The wording of the GPL ensures that if Alice receives it under GPL3, she is guaranteed the right to distribute under GPL3, otherwise Bob is breaking the terms of the licence.

Cheers,
Wol


to post comments

GCC drops its copyright-assignment requirement

Posted Jun 10, 2021 6:31 UTC (Thu) by matthias (subscriber, #94967) [Link]

> WORDS MATTER! Where in the GPL does it say that Alice GRANTS a licence TO Carol? It says that Carol GETS a licence FROM Alice. That's not the same thing at all!

No, it uses the word RECEIVES, again a word with a completely different meaning. Or not so different at all? How do you get a license? By a grant!

And the important thing is not whether Carol gets, receives, or is granted a license. The important hing is which license she gets. And the GPL version 3 is very specific about that: Carol gets a license GPL version 3.

> And seeing as the only licence Alice has granted is GPL2+, that is the licence Carol gets.

Why? Just because Alice did never grant before a license GPL3? How can you conclude that she will not in the future? She definitely has the right to do so. And the terms of her chosen license terms (GPL2+) state that exactly that will happen once the code is distributed under GPL3.

> For her to get anything else, she must have received that licence from Bob, which the GPL explicitly says DOES NOT HAPPEN.

No, she can receive that anything else from Alice. And the GPL says she will get it from Alice. No problem there.

> Plus, how come Bob has not forwarded to Carol the right he had to choose ANY licence allowed by GPL2+? The GPL itself says that that is what the GPL seeks to enforce.

It does not say this. The GPL3 (int the very license terms) only says that the freedoms according to the terms of GPL3 have to be forwarded.

> The wording of the GPL ensures that if Alice receives it under GPL3, she is guaranteed the right to distribute under GPL3, otherwise Bob is breaking the terms of the licence.

Probably, you mean Carol. I think, we agree on this. But I do not see how this is broken if Bob replace GPL2+ by GPL3. Carol can still distribute under GPL3.

> But in this case, Bob has *changed* *the* *licence*.

Again, Bob did not change any license. The licence Carol gets from Alice is specified by GPL3 and the existence of this license only starts, once Carol receives the code. How can you change something that does not yet exist?

> And again, where in the GPL does it say Alice GRANTS a licence? I've looked at clause 10 and it uses the word GET, which is a completely different word, with a completely different meaning.

See above. And did you really look at clause 10? How did you miss that it says RECEIVES and not GET? ;)

Best,
Matthias


Copyright © 2026, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds