GCC drops its copyright-assignment requirement
GCC drops its copyright-assignment requirement
Posted Jun 9, 2021 23:38 UTC (Wed) by Wol (subscriber, #4433)In reply to: GCC drops its copyright-assignment requirement by matthias
Parent article: GCC drops its copyright-assignment requirement
WORDS MATTER! Where in the GPL does it say that Alice GRANTS a licence TO Carol? It says that Carol GETS a licence FROM Alice. That's not the same thing at all! And seeing as the only licence Alice has granted is GPL2+, that is the licence Carol gets. For her to get anything else, she must have received that licence from Bob, which the GPL explicitly says DOES NOT HAPPEN.
Plus, how come Bob has not forwarded to Carol the right he had to choose ANY licence allowed by GPL2+? The GPL itself says that that is what the GPL seeks to enforce. And if the GPL explicitly states its intent, then a Judge is likely to say that is a requirement, pre-amble or no.
The wording of the GPL ensures that if Alice receives it under GPL3, she is guaranteed the right to distribute under GPL3, otherwise Bob is breaking the terms of the licence.
Cheers,
Wol
