PipeWire: The Linux audio/video bus

LP wasn't joking about breaking sound: things did break, many, many times for many, many people, for years. And, almost always the only information readily available about what went wrong was just sound no longer coming out, or going in. And, almost always the reliable fix was to delete PA.

But it really was often a consequence of something broken outside of PA. That doesn't mean there was always nothing the PA developers could do, and often they did. The only way it all ended up working as well as it does today--pretty well--is that those things finally got done, and bulldozed through the distro release pipelines. The result was that we gradually stopped needing to delete PA.

Gstreamer crashed all the damn time, for a very long time, too. I never saw PA crash much.

The thing is, all that most of us wanted, almost all the time, was for exactly one program to operate on sound at any time, with exactly one input device and one output device. UI warbling and meeping was never a high-value process. Mixing was most of the time an unnecessary complication and source of latency. The only complicated thing most of us ever wanted was to change routing to and from a headset when it was plugged or unplugged. ALSA was often wholly good enough at that.

To this day, I have UI warbling and meeping turned off, not because it is still broken or might crash gstreamer, but because it is a net-negative feature. I am happiest that it is mostly easy to turn off. (I *wish* I could make my phone not scritch every damn time it sees a new wifi hub.)

Pipewire benefits from things fixed to make PA work, so I have expectations that the transition will be quicker. But Pipewire is (like PA and Systemd) coded in a language that makes correct code much harder to write than buggy, insecure code; and Pipewire relies on not always necessarily especially mature kernel facilities. Those are both risk factors. I would be happier if Pipewire were coded in modern C++ (Rust is--let's be honest, at least with ourselves!--not portable enough yet), for reliability and security. I would be happier if it used only mature kernel features in its core operations, and dodgy new stuff only where needed for correspondingly dodgy Bluetooth configurations that nobody, seriously, expects ever to work anyway.

What would go a long way to smoothing the transition would be a way to see, graphically, where it has stopped working. The graph in the article, annotated in real time with flow rates, sample rates, bit depths, buffer depths, and attenuation figures, would give us a hint about what is failing, with a finer resolution than "damn Pipewire". If we had such a thing for PA, it might have generated less animosity.