A report from the documentation maintainer

Posted Nov 7, 2016 11:20 UTC (Mon) by idrys (subscriber, #4347)
In reply to: A report from the documentation maintainer by johill
Parent article: A report from the documentation maintainer

(native speaker here as well)

While this matching helps with words that can simply be written in two ways, I'd be rather surprised to get a match for a different word (like in Maßen vs. in Massen). And I think the new orthography is, for the most part, horrible (it emphasized writing over reading while neglecting that you know what you're writing but your reader doesn't). But adherents of the old orthography will die out over time anyway :/

to post comments

A report from the documentation maintainer

Posted Nov 7, 2016 13:45 UTC (Mon) by farnz (subscriber, #17727) [Link] (2 responses)

Hmm. Are you saying that, when doing a case-insensitive match, you'd really want the computer to be aware of the intended dictionary word? So that a search for "groß" matches all of "GROSS", "groß" and "gross" (leaving your human intelligence to determine which ones are "good" matches), while a search for "maßen" should match "Maßen" but not "MASSEN" or "Massen", because "Maßen" and "Massen" are different words? Or is there an underlying rule that I'm not seeing (something like "Maßen" should match "MASSEN" as an all-caps Maßen and "maßen" as missing the initial capital, but not "Massen" or "massen" because the casing rules let you see that ss was deliberate, not the result of round-tripping through upper case back to lower case)?

A report from the documentation maintainer

Posted Nov 7, 2016 14:30 UTC (Mon) by idrys (subscriber, #4347) [Link] (1 responses)

I'd prefer to not match eszet vs. double-s at all, generally. I understand and to a degree follow the reasoning, but I think it would cause more confusion than not. (And your example neatly illustrates this; too much side-knowledge required.)

I _could_ imagine an exception for eszet vs. upper-case double-s, but I'd be surprised if 'grep -i maßen' would find MASSEN as well... (And what about 'SZ' as a capitalization for 'ß'? It is now extremely uncommon, but I've seen this in documents up to the mid-20th century.)

[As an aside, old documents are sometimes inconsistent for eszet vs. double-s in people's names as well, as they sometimes capitalized names and sometimes not, so this is not a new issue. We are not 100% sure what the family name on my mother's side is for that reason. Oh well...]

A report from the documentation maintainer

Posted Nov 7, 2016 16:52 UTC (Mon) by mathstuf (subscriber, #69389) [Link]

FYI, there also exist ligature codepoints like `ﬁ` would need to be split apart on uppercase.