The EFF launches a router project [LWN.net]

The EFF launches a router project

Posted Aug 1, 2014 4:21 UTC (Fri) by mtaht (guest, #11087)
In reply to: The EFF launches a router project by jhhaller
Parent article: The EFF launches a router project

cool, thanks, good to know! The kind of numbers that intel gets out of their SDK are *amazing* - and I wasn't aware that there was a similar effort on arm. The thing is, intel gets those numbers by having DMA direct to their very large caches, which arm chips generally lack.

I keep hoping someone writing hardware will make note of all the advancements in queue theory of late and make better ethernet chips (or, in arm's case, verilog or VHDL IP).

to post comments

The EFF launches a router project

Posted Aug 1, 2014 12:27 UTC (Fri) by arnd (guest, #8866) [Link] (1 responses)

My understanding of DPDK and ODP is that they are mostly interested in running proprietary network stacks in user space, in order to implement features there that don't exist in the kernel, but at the same time completely bypassing the kernel and the features that exist in it. The fact that Intel and some others can do DMA into caches is independent of that and you can do that in both kernel and user space based network stacks.

Note that ODP by design requires cache-coherent DMA, which does not necessarily imply doing the DMA into the cache, but it does mean that it is not portable to the typical low-end SoCs you'd find in consumer routers as opposed to the devices that Cisco and Juniper are selling to enterprise customers.

The ArmadaXP chip (used in WRT1900AC) may be an exception to that, so ODP can run on that in theory, but then you still need to program your ODP based application to talk to Marvell's network hardware through ODP.

The EFF launches a router project

Posted Feb 15, 2016 13:13 UTC (Mon) by nysan (subscriber, #81015) [Link]

"My understanding of DPDK and ODP is that they are mostly interested in running proprietary network stacks in user space, in order to implement features there that don't exist in the kernel, but at the same time completely bypassing the kernel and the features that exist in it. The fact that Intel and some others can do DMA into caches is independent of that and you can do that in both kernel and user space based network stacks."

Have a look at openfastpath on ODP.
Linux is still used as controlplane with --enable-sp, ARP, RIPv2 et.c. is sent to the kernel stack.
Standard cmds "arp", "ip" et.c. are used to configure parts of the stack thats common between both.
Control plane stack state is mirrored via netlink for fast access by packet churning cores, i.e. ARP table, FIB et.c.