Calling syscalls from the kernel [LWN.net]

Calling syscalls from the kernel

Posted Jul 23, 2014 14:32 UTC (Wed) by YogeshC (guest, #49966)
In reply to: Calling syscalls from the kernel by drysdale
Parent article: Anatomy of a system call, part 1

In that case, why has this particular syscall been used in half a dozen places inside the kernel? Is there any specific (or general) reason(s) for read/write syscalls to be called from within the kernel space on so many occasions?

to post comments

Calling syscalls from the kernel

Posted Aug 11, 2014 12:45 UTC (Mon) by rwmj (subscriber, #5474) [Link]

No one answered your question so I'll have a go.

The main user of sys_read at the moment is the code for unpacking the initramfs. You could imagine this "should" be done by a userspace process, because it's doing a lot of userspace-type stuff, like uncompressing a cpio file and then creating a tree of directories and files from it. It's nearly the equivalent of running:

  zcat initramfs | cpio -id

However because the initramfs is needed before userspace is up -- because creating the initramfs is creating the initial userspace -- they have to do this userspace-type stuff in the kernel instead.

So it's a layering violation, but for understandable reasons.