Google should strip out unreferenced symbols... but it probably doesn't matter
Google should strip out unreferenced symbols... but it probably doesn't matter
Posted Mar 21, 2011 15:31 UTC (Mon) by dank (guest, #1865)In reply to: Google should strip out unreferenced symbols... but it probably doesn't matter by wahern
Parent article: Has Bionic stepped over the GPL line?
0) Semantic information needed for userspace (libc or apps) to interoperate
with the kernel via public interfaces is either noncopyrightable because it's a published interface intended to be publicly usable, and/or can be used without infringing because Linus said so
1) The expression of that information in a particular header is copyrightable
2) A compiler or other semantic analyzer can extract the noncopyrightable
semantic information from a copyrighted header and dump it to a new sanitized header without infringing the header's copyright
3) Google intended to do that, but didn't quite do a thorough job, so there may be some residue of expressive, non-required, copyrightable code in the headers
4) The residue is probably not being referenced by Bionic or any third-party apps, so there are probably no infringing derivative works
5) Google could reduce the amount of residue if they wanted by adding
another scrubbing pass in the header filter code to remove symbols
not referenced by bionic libc or the apps that come with android
(and for that matter, replacing all possibly expressive whitespace);
this would strengthen their case that removing the license notices
is appropriate. Doing so now would be a fine example of responding to
a possible GPL violation in good faith.
6) Semantic information needed for kernel modules to interoperate
with the kernel via nonpublic interfaces is another matter, and does
not affect the Bionic discussion
The LWN site is currently under high scraper load, so comment display has been suppressed for anonymous users. If you are a human, you may read the comments by clicking the button below:
Note: you can avoid this step in the future by logging into your LWN account.
