Untz: Results of the App Installer meeting, and some thoughts on cross-distro collaboration
Untz: Results of the App Installer meeting, and some thoughts on cross-distro collaboration
Posted Jan 26, 2011 9:08 UTC (Wed) by xav (guest, #18536)In reply to: Untz: Results of the App Installer meeting, and some thoughts on cross-distro collaboration by rahulsundaram
Parent article: Untz: Results of the App Installer meeting, and some thoughts on cross-distro collaboration
This has nothing to do with the technical side of installation. Let me try to explain my point of view to you:
- when running e.g. Debian, Ubuntu or Fedora, the end-user has an expectation of stability and security
- that's because the pool of package managers is known, they all talk together and respect a set of common rules, and are reactive to events (e.g. security alerts)
- and that's because the end-user is sort-of restricted in what it can install on its machine, that is packages from the distribution; only so-called power users will install alternative packages
- now you want anyone being able to set up a blinking webpage telling users "install that shiny new GonzoMediaPlayer to be able to watch football matches for free"
- there you are, your rock stable linux distribution is now down to a Windows machine, with anyone being able to distribute malware for any distribution, and unknowledgeable end-users' systems plagued with it
- when running e.g. Debian, Ubuntu or Fedora, the end-user has an expectation of stability and security
- that's because the pool of package managers is known, they all talk together and respect a set of common rules, and are reactive to events (e.g. security alerts)
- and that's because the end-user is sort-of restricted in what it can install on its machine, that is packages from the distribution; only so-called power users will install alternative packages
- now you want anyone being able to set up a blinking webpage telling users "install that shiny new GonzoMediaPlayer to be able to watch football matches for free"
- there you are, your rock stable linux distribution is now down to a Windows machine, with anyone being able to distribute malware for any distribution, and unknowledgeable end-users' systems plagued with it
I see the fact that executables must go through a distro-specific packaging process first as a virtue, not a defect. Apparently not everyone agree.
