|
|
Log in / Subscribe / Register

New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)

New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)

Posted Jan 24, 2011 7:41 UTC (Mon) by FlorianMueller (guest, #32048)
In reply to: New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica) by designerfx
Parent article: New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)

You are completely wrong on all counts.

Your claim that it's "GPL'd code" is only partially accurate. Some of the code I identified was never GPL'd. Other is under a permissive license that does, however, have requirements that weren't met. And some of the code is still proprietary.

At least a large part if not all of the code was *obtained* by the Android team on non-GPL terms.

Even though a GPL violation is ideally resolved with an amicable arrangement (source code release etc.), an illegal relicensing from GPL to Apache can have legal consequences beyond just an obligation to accept copyleft in going forward. An infringement is an infringement under the law.

And the code has not been "removed". My follow-up blog post explains this. It was removed only from the source tree for *future* versions. It's still( or still was when I blogged) in the source trees of Android 2.2 (Froyo) and 2.3 (Gingerbread). It's also in the source availability packages of major Android devices such as Galaxy Tab, Droid X, Ally, Optimus. So much for "removal".


to post comments

New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)

Posted Jan 24, 2011 13:23 UTC (Mon) by designerfx (guest, #72536) [Link] (6 responses)

the code has been removed and it is not being used.

so your comment is moot before it starts.

New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)

Posted Jan 24, 2011 13:32 UTC (Mon) by FlorianMueller (guest, #32048) [Link] (5 responses)

It's wrong to say it's been removed. It's still online on the Android source website (Froyo and Gingerbread builds, which are the two most important ones at this stage); it's still online on Motorola's, LG's and Samsung's websites, which are pretty important manufacturers; and who knows where else it is.

"Not being used" -- ask the OEMs who distribute it as part of their official source release packages for devices like the Galaxy Tab, Droid X, Ally, Optimus.

New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)

Posted Jan 24, 2011 18:30 UTC (Mon) by designerfx (guest, #72536) [Link] (4 responses)

you are 100% wrong here.

available means you need to look at the people who are using it in the distribution. Google is not responsible for that.

you can put out code for anything, including GPL infringing stuff, but that doesn't mean you are a: inducing infringement (unless proven in court), or b: that you're liable for what *others* do with it.

maybe you don't understand. it's on the device, but it's not being used. Additionally, the headers were simply wrong, and you refused to acknowledge that (and still fail to).

It's being removed from future distribution, and that's the end of google's responsibility. It's up to samsung, or whoever, to remove if it it even matters, or just let it not be included when they move gingerbread downstream, which will happen by default.

thus, you are making a nonexistent issue which is completely moot, sound like an issue, when it is not.

meanwhile, how much of this has been validated by any court?

Let me provide you the amount: zero.

New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)

Posted Jan 24, 2011 18:36 UTC (Mon) by FlorianMueller (guest, #32048) [Link] (1 responses)

Let me focus on just one of the things you said: inducing infringement.

Taking code that's under a proprietary license or under the GPL and relicensing it illegally under Apache and publishing the relicensed version for the world to download and use could certainly result in situations (if people download the code and use it in reliance upon the false headers) that would raise liability issues.

New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)

Posted Jan 24, 2011 21:34 UTC (Mon) by Wol (subscriber, #4433) [Link]

I thought it was now ACCEPTED FACT that Google DIDN'T do that!

Some anonymous coward put it onto Google's servers. It was AC that did what you're claiming.

There's a damn good chance that NOBODY at Google was even aware the stuff was there until you pointed it out to them ... (so they should be thanking you for bringing it to their notice!-)

Cheers,
Wol

New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)

Posted Jan 24, 2011 20:33 UTC (Mon) by jspaleta (subscriber, #50639) [Link] (1 responses)

I think your interpretation as to what constitutes "inducing infringement" is overly optimistic. I believe past examples of court rulings involving contributor infringement of a website operator as something as innocent as linking to infringing code sitting on another server says, to me at least, that taking a hopeful view that a court of law will make an informed judgement that makes sense in the context of internet cultural norms is not a rational way to approach any potential copyright infringement lawsuit. It's a great way to get your ass handed to you when the company bringing the lawsuit does their dog and pony show in front of the judge and you aren't prepared to strongly push back against their arguments with comprehensive arguments of your own.

This isn't settled law at all and it really comes down to the proclivities of the particular judge presiding over the case and how knowledgeable they are about the technology, the cultural norms and current best practises in the context of the copyright violation being presented. It's simply not prudent to offhandedly discard these copyright violations as inconsequential. If Oracle builds a case that includes these violations as examples, Google will have to be prepared to show with specificity that these violations caused non-material harm to Oracle and that they have been proactive in correcting them as a means to limit any judgement award a judge may give to Oracle. Even then Google may not be able to get out of paying for Oracle's legal fees if the court decided there are violations of a non-material nature.

It would absolutely suck for everyone if Oracle was able to convince a judge that they deserve a payout for violations of this nature. But you can't just assume that's how a court case will go the way that seems sane to the rest of us.

-jef

New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)

Posted Jan 25, 2011 4:17 UTC (Tue) by designerfx (guest, #72536) [Link]

unless a court declares this case as inducing infringement it is nothing but speculation and fud trying to claim that there's a potential risk here.

we are not lawyers, and we do not know.

yet is florian implying that it's a risk?

he sure did.


Copyright © 2026, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds