New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)
New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)
Posted Jan 24, 2011 7:41 UTC (Mon) by FlorianMueller (guest, #32048)In reply to: New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica) by designerfx
Parent article: New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)
Your claim that it's "GPL'd code" is only partially accurate. Some of the code I identified was never GPL'd. Other is under a permissive license that does, however, have requirements that weren't met. And some of the code is still proprietary.
At least a large part if not all of the code was *obtained* by the Android team on non-GPL terms.
Even though a GPL violation is ideally resolved with an amicable arrangement (source code release etc.), an illegal relicensing from GPL to Apache can have legal consequences beyond just an obligation to accept copyleft in going forward. An infringement is an infringement under the law.
And the code has not been "removed". My follow-up blog post explains this. It was removed only from the source tree for *future* versions. It's still( or still was when I blogged) in the source trees of Android 2.2 (Froyo) and 2.3 (Gingerbread). It's also in the source availability packages of major Android devices such as Galaxy Tab, Droid X, Ally, Optimus. So much for "removal".
