|
|
Log in / Subscribe / Register

New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)

New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)

Posted Jan 22, 2011 0:56 UTC (Sat) by kripkenstein (guest, #43281)
In reply to: New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica) by FlorianMueller
Parent article: New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)

> Taking proprietary or GPL'd code and putting it under the Apache license can result in all sorts of liability issues if third parties obtain it and build it into products (software, hardware, whatever) in reliance upon the license header.

Doing that could result in massive liability. But, that is not what happened - Google did not put this code under the Apache license:

1. Google did not delete original copyright and licensing texts and replace them with the Apache license.

2. Google does not release Android under the Apache license, simply because that is impossible - a massive part of Android, the Linux kernel, is not Apache licensed. Many other parts are likewise not Apache licensed, and Google has never claimed every file in Android is Apache licensed. What Google has done, is release much of its new code in Android - like Dalvik - under the Apache license, but not even all of Google code in Android has that license (Google modifications to the kernel, for example, are GPLed). So there is no legitimate cause to assume that all files in Android are Apache licensed, as Google never claimed as much.

> a copyright infringement is a copyright infringement.

There are very different kinds. Copyright infringement that causes direct and grievous harm - say, by hacking into a company's servers, copying their code, and using that to copy their business, leading to direct losses - would have far more of an argument for an injunction or monetary compensation, than mistakenly copying a file in a way that does not lead to actual harm.

Of course what Google did (assuming the facts are correct) is illegal and wrong - copying those files was copyright infringement. And if it *does* lead to actual harm, in some unexpected way, it may be greatly liable. For that reason companies try to avoid such mistakes. However, this is still very different from intentional copyright infringement that does cause actual harm. The liability in these files seems very minor.


to post comments

New alleged evidence of Android infringement isn't a smoking gun (ars technica)

Posted Jan 23, 2011 16:29 UTC (Sun) by jmalcolm (subscriber, #8876) [Link]

Great comment.


Copyright © 2026, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds