|
|
Log in / Subscribe / Register

STOP IT PLEASE ~ THERE IS *NO* DANGER.

STOP IT PLEASE ~ THERE IS *NO* DANGER.

Posted May 28, 2007 3:06 UTC (Mon) by KenWPeek (guest, #45462)
Parent article: Microsoft takes on the free world (CNN)

|
PLEASE STOP ALL OF THIS NONSENSE!

Patent Law, is *NOT* the same as Copyright Law.

The *ONLY* thing the US government grants to the patent holder is: "The exclusive right to market the invention...". In this sentence, "market" is a verb. Let's look up the meaning of "to market" in Black's Law dictionary (use the older dictionary that was available at the time the law was written.) The verb "to market" means: "to sell, or offer for sale, or license the sale of". Also, when a patent is issued, the US Government is automatically granted a perpetual non-exclusive license to the technology for FREE.

If no money changes hands for a product, then the product was *NOT* "sold".

*ALL* distributors of free software that I know of GIVE AWAY FOR FREE the software-- though some of them charge a fee for the media and/or service of burning the FREE software onto a disk.

*NO* "end user" of a patented technology can be sued for "patent infringement", because they are *NOT* selling a product incorporating the patented technology.

Microsoft's assertions of "patent infringement" DO NOT APPLY TO END USERS, PERIOD. AND THAT MEANS CORPORATIONS TOO (which are just "paper persons".)

Microsoft's assertions of patent infringement DO NOT APPLY TO DISTRIBUTORS OF FREE PRODUCTS OF ANY KIND.

The only exception to this is for the non-GPL-type licenses (BSD, MIT, etc.), where the distributor of the software chooses to charge money for the software. Then, and only then may Microsoft's assertions of "patent infringement" apply, and then only if the patents are found to be valid, and only if the software sold uses the patented technology.

As a veteran of patent infringement lawsuits, allow me to explain how this all works.

In order to keep it's patent rights, a patent holder (Microsoft in this case) *MUST* begin proceedings against the alleged "patent infringer". This is called "due diligence", and there is a time limit set forth in case law for this. The clock begins as soon as the patent holder realizes that a patented technology is (possibly) being infringed. If you inform the alleged infringer within six months, you are on solid ground, and longer than that is "questionable" (you better have a good reason!) The proceedings begin by sending a "Cease and Desist" letter to the alleged patent infringer. The letter *MUST* state the specific patent number, and *MUST* state specifically how the person or company is infringing (or is "about to" infringe by offering a product for sale). For software products, this would at least show the product that the alleged infringer is offering for sale, and *HOW* that product allegedly infringes on the patent holder's technology. If this information is not provided, case law holds that the alleged infringer has *NOT* been "noticed" (given sufficient notice) of the infringement, and the process has not yet begun. The patent holder may *NOT* wait until sufficient damages have accrued before beginning to exercise "due diligence", because the court is likely to declare that the alleged patent infringer has been given permission (by "default") due to insufficient notice in a timely manner, and this *CAN* cause the patent to end up in the public domain.

So, let's assume that sufficient notice begins. The two parties may engage in a dialog to further define the alleged infringement, and if the alleged infringer then agrees that they are infringing, they can either decide to stop infringing immediately, or to work out a licensing deal with the patent holder. (The latter is the usual course taken.)

If the alleged infringer does *NOT* agree that infringement is taking place (for various reasons, like: 1) they are not selling anything or offering anything for sale, or 2) they think the patent is not valid due to one or more reasons, or 3) or they believe that their product uses a different technology than what the patent holder is claiming that they are using, etc.) The two parties will now begin court proceedings. This usually begins by the patent holder filing a lawsuit against the alleged infringer, who then in turn usually motions the court for a "show cause" hearing (which is almost always granted.) In this "show cause" hearing, the patent holder *MUST* show proof of the exact product that the alleged infringer *SOLD* (or offers for sale if no sale has yet occurred), and the exact manner and method that the alleged infringement is occurring. If insufficient evidence is provided that shows that clearly shows that infringement is taking place, the judge will dismiss the case, and that is the end of it. If the judge believes that there is sufficient evidence that infringement occurred, then a trial date will be set, and at this time the patent holder usually motions the court for injunctive relief (to stop the alleged infringer from selling the products in question until the matter is resolved in court.) In these kinds of cases, the motion for injunctive relief is usually denied, but the judge will order the alleged infringer to keep accurate record of all sales (in case they lose the case, the infringer will have to surrender all proceeds of any sales.)

So, as you can see from the above, Microsoft would never make it past the "show cause" hearing stage, because no products are being sold, and no there is no intention to sell any products. (Indeed, the GPL forbids the sale of the GPL'd software for any amount of money.)

END-OF-LAWSUIT. GAME OVER.

So (for example) if you download a FREE ISO image of "Ubuntu Linux" from a server in South Africa, burn the ISO image onto a CD, and install the software, Microsoft has no "standing" in court, because: 1) You are an end-user of the product, and you are not selling the product or offering it for sale, and 2) South Africa (wisely) does not recognize "software patents", and so no lawsuit can be filed in that country. In this case, Microsoft is simply left out in the cold, and can do *NOTHING* (without being counter-sued for a "frivolous lawsuit", and THEY would LOSE.)

So, unless you *KNOW* what you are talking about, please quit with all of the "worry talk". It is just scaring everyone, and is only *helping* Microsoft with their "Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt" [FUD] campaign.
|


to post comments


Copyright © 2026, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds