|
|
Log in / Subscribe / Register

Work w/o publication is not science

Work w/o publication is not science

Posted Apr 24, 2026 11:02 UTC (Fri) by khim (subscriber, #9252)
In reply to: Work w/o publication is not science by spacefrogg
Parent article: A more efficient implementation of Shor's algorithm

> Publishing one's results is an integral, that is, non-disputable, part of modern science.

Yes, and it's time to accept that this science is dead. It was dead for a long time, it just now becomes more and more apparent. “Modern science” have focused so much on publishing to the detriment of discovery that is stopped producing meaningful results long ago. All the important discoveries happen these days not in the “modern science” institutions but in places you so despise: either outright sponsored by corporations or the “joint projects” when someone needs to feel that they want to do “official science”. The “modern science” industry is now churning out “minimum viable publications” that don't actually advance anything, but just ensure that someone have did enough work to give them some diploma or another paper of appreciation.

> The "publication" is academic circle jerking and serves no other purpose as to improve the researchers' feeling of self-importance.

Sure, but it also highlights the fact that there are some actual research is happening somewhere… publications of “modern science” are not showing even that…

> If you feel attacked by this, I don't really care what you have to say to this. Actions speak louder than words. Properly publish or get out of my sun.

Nice temper tantrum…


to post comments

Work w/o publication is not science

Posted Apr 24, 2026 12:58 UTC (Fri) by pizza (subscriber, #46) [Link] (3 responses)

>> Publishing one's results is an integral, that is, non-disputable, part of modern science.
> Yes, and it's time to accept that this science is dead.

Uh, nothing you wrote refutes his point of the necessity of *publishing one's work*

Even if one's work is self-wanking junk; whether or not it's on a blog or a [formerly-]respected reviewed journal; it still needs to be published to be of any value.

Work w/o publication is not science

Posted Apr 24, 2026 14:01 UTC (Fri) by khim (subscriber, #9252) [Link] (2 responses)

> it still needs to be published to be of any value

Why? You can do certain decision just on the basis of existence of certain things.

Plus you may withold publication for the same reason that made Gelileo publish smaismrmil­mepoeta­leumibu­nenugt­tauiras, instead of full article — and for many others.

> Uh, nothing you wrote refutes his point of the necessity of *publishing one's work*

It's the same ages-long discussion about free software and open-source software, I'm afraid. In fact “modern science” demonstrated the perils of hypothetical pure “free software” world. If publication becomes the main goal of research then Goodhart's law very quickly ensures that institutions built around that paradigm start producing increasingly large numbers of increasingly useless papers… precisely what have happened with “modern science”.

And when actual research moves into places where publication may not be the main goal (or may not even be a goal at all)… we observe these funny temper tantrums…

Work w/o publication is not science

Posted Apr 24, 2026 15:12 UTC (Fri) by pizza (subscriber, #46) [Link] (1 responses)

> Why? You can do certain decision just on the basis of existence of certain things.

Pray tell, how do you know that thing exists at all?

FYI, I don't mean "publish" as in "run the gauntlet of a peer review scientific journal", I mean in the literal "put the !$%!%^# thing in a place where someone -- anyone -- else is able to find and do something with it."

(This "someone" might just be the bean counters whose metrics you're trying to game. Or it could be a larger community that is genuinely trying to expand our understanding of the universe. Either way, if it's not made available to someone other than you, it's worthless to everyone...including you!)

Let’s stop here

Posted Apr 24, 2026 16:11 UTC (Fri) by jzb (editor, #7867) [Link]

Getting a bit off topic here.


Copyright © 2026, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds