|
|
Log in / Subscribe / Register

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Posted Mar 23, 2026 14:01 UTC (Mon) by Wol (subscriber, #4433)
In reply to: Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?) by paulj
Parent article: Google details new 24-hour process to sideload unverified Android apps (Ars Technica)

> I havn't seen one in decades in the Celtic Isles.

I've still got a bunch of cheque books. I still use them occasionally.

> Likes of NL never really used cheques (in my lifetime) - you did a "giro", which I guess was pretty much the same system as DE. Just a straight bank transfer back in the day to pay someone. Giro form was somewhat standardised and businesses could print a giro form with all their details already filled in with their invoice to make it easy to pay them. As you say, you just added your own details and handed it in (or posted it) to your bank branch and it would be taken care of. No bad cheques!

Sounds like a "giro" as you call it was just a standard paying in slip (I thought it was something else). There's never been any need for the person paying in, and the bank account, to be related in any way. If you know the account details you're paying into, you can pay into pretty much any account. Banks do tend to want the details on the standard slip, though, if you're doing it in person at a branch (I believe so they can check the details - money laundering and all that stuff).

Cheers,
Wol


to post comments

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Posted Mar 23, 2026 16:05 UTC (Mon) by anselm (subscriber, #2796) [Link] (1 responses)

Sounds like a "giro" as you call it was just a standard paying in slip (I thought it was something else). There's never been any need for the person paying in, and the bank account, to be related in any way. If you know the account details you're paying into, you can pay into pretty much any account.

Not quite. The idea is to tell your bank to take X amount from your account P and transfer it to another person's or company's account Q, possibly at a completely different bank. No actual money is involved. Way back when, the bank had little paper forms for you to fill out, but now this is mostly online, and in fact according to new regulations in the EU must be able to be performed in real-time. (Back in the days of the little paper forms the banks would take a few days to sort things out and put the money to good use on their own behalf in the meantime – nowadays they have 10 seconds to get their act together. The banks really, really hate this because now they must track every transaction on its own, where in the old days bank X would just total up, overnight, everything going from it to bank Y on that day and bank Y would total up everything going from it to bank X on that day, and they would figure out the difference and settle up in a single transaction.)

When I used to live in the UK (a few decades ago, to be fair) I was appalled when I opened my bank account and the bank guy handed me a cheque book. I found out to my horror that direct giro transfers (even with the little paper forms) weren't actually a thing in the UK, even though cheques had already been virtually abolished here in Germany at the time. It felt like the Middle Ages to me.

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Posted Mar 23, 2026 17:05 UTC (Mon) by Wol (subscriber, #4433) [Link]

> Not quite. The idea is to tell your bank to take X amount from your account P and transfer it to another person's or company's account Q, possibly at a completely different bank. No actual money is involved.

Not quite? Yes exactly!

I just walk into my bank with my bank card and the paying-in slip, and say "please transfer £X" (actually, I would probably have already filled in X). No actual money is involved!

(If I couldn't attend the bank during banking hours, I regularly stapled the paying-in slip to a cheque, and posted it through the letter box.)

In your scenario, how does your bank know where to take the money FROM? Fill that in, and our two scenarios are exactly identical.

Cheers,
Wol

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Posted Mar 23, 2026 16:53 UTC (Mon) by paulj (subscriber, #341) [Link] (11 responses)

> Sounds like a "giro" as you call it was just a standard paying in slip (I thought it was something else).

Kind of, but a bit more formalised. The deposit and transfer slips in Celtic Isle banks tended to be bank-specific and vary a bit between them. You would get the slip from your own bank, and you would fill it in.

The giro slips (apparently 'acceptgiro' is the full term, but IIRC everyone just said 'giro', but ICBM) in NL were standardised, and they came pre-filled in with the bank details of the recipient. Businesses issuing invoices often also printed in the required amount, and there was space for stuff like an invoice/refernece number. The payer then took/received/got the 'acceptgiro' from the payee (recipient), put their own details in and gave/sent the completed giro slip to their bank and payment would be made by the payer's bank to the payee's.

I.e., it worked the /other way/ around from the anglo cheque system. The payee gave the slip with the payee's details to the payer, and the payer would give the slip to their bank to make the payment. Where the cheque, the payer had a book of slips with the payer's details, which they filled in with the payee's details, and gave to the payee for the payee to give to the payee's bank to /request/ payment from the payer's.

Push Vs pull. Also, acceptgiros were cleared and reconciled within days usually - where cheques often took 1 to 2 weeks to reconcile (cheque reconciliation requiring the extra step of that first 'pull' communication from the payee's bank to the payer's).

I gather giros could also be used to setup recurring payments. I don't have experience of that though.

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Posted Mar 23, 2026 17:19 UTC (Mon) by Wol (subscriber, #4433) [Link] (10 responses)

> The giro slips (apparently 'acceptgiro' is the full term, but IIRC everyone just said 'giro', but ICBM) in NL were standardised, and they came pre-filled in with the bank details of the recipient. Businesses issuing invoices often also printed in the required amount, and there was space for stuff like an invoice/refernece number. The payer then took/received/got the 'acceptgiro' from the payee (recipient), put their own details in and gave/sent the completed giro slip to their bank and payment would be made by the payer's bank to the payee's.

> I.e., it worked the /other way/ around from the anglo cheque system. The payee gave the slip with the payee's details to the payer, and the payer would give the slip to their bank to make the payment. Where the cheque, the payer had a book of slips with the payer's details, which they filled in with the payee's details, and gave to the payee for the payee to give to the payee's bank to /request/ payment from the payer's.

??????

Bear in mind I'm not talking a couple of decades ago, I'm talking a lifetime ago, ... your two scenarios are the exact same scenario, just described in two different ways!

The British banking system requires TWO pieces of information - where the money is coming from, and where it is going to. Seen in that light, there is absolutely no difference between a giro and a paying in slip. They both provide the "where it's going to".

The payer (in both your scenario and mine) has to provide the "where it is coming from".

So let's take a concrete example. A business sends me a bill, with a "giro" printed on the bottom. I take it to the bank and pay it. I want some money from a friend, I give them a paying-in slip, they take it to a bank and hand over the money.

As for how long it takes to clear, if I walk into a bank with a debit card to pay the "giro" it clears instantly. If I staple a cheque to it, it clears like any other cheque (which is basically down to a - then somewhat antiquated - nightly batch processing system. It's improved a lot since).

So what I was doing forty years ago exactly matches BOTH of your scenarios, depending on how it was done. Your "acceptgiro" is exactly the same as our cheque system, except that the payee printed the cheque, not the bank!

Cheers,
Wol

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Posted Mar 23, 2026 22:18 UTC (Mon) by kleptog (subscriber, #1183) [Link] (9 responses)

> So what I was doing forty years ago exactly matches BOTH of your scenarios, depending on how it was done. Your "acceptgiro" is exactly the same as our cheque system, except that the payee printed the cheque, not the bank!

Your examples are not making very clear which bank you're going to. I know in Australia we could print a pay-in slip on the invoice but it only worked for one bank and people had to go to that bank to pay it. The magic of acceptgiro was that it was standardised and that you submitted your payments your own bank. You basically received invoices in the mail, tore off the slips, filled in your details and then mailed them all to your bank. Since your own bank has your signature on file, it cleared quickly.

What make cheques slow is that the bank receiving the cheque doesn't have the info to verify it. Unless you're saying in the UK you could mail a cheque to your own bank to get money transferred? I didn't think it worked like that.

Your example of stapling a cheque to pay-in slip makes little sense if you're submitting to your own bank. The teller can simply execute the payment on the spot.

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Posted Mar 24, 2026 8:24 UTC (Tue) by Wol (subscriber, #4433) [Link] (8 responses)

> Your examples are not making very clear which bank you're going to. I know in Australia we could print a pay-in slip on the invoice but it only worked for one bank and people had to go to that bank to pay it. The magic of acceptgiro was that it was standardised and that you submitted your payments your own bank. You basically received invoices in the mail, tore off the slips, filled in your details and then mailed them all to your bank. Since your own bank has your signature on file, it cleared quickly.

All official slips (both cheques and paying in slips) had the account details in a standard ocr-friendly font at the bottom, in a standard layout.

Otherwise, how would you pay your cheque into someone else's bank? Generally a bank would refuse to accept the payment unless it was either the payer's bank or the payee's. But you could take it to any bank and they could process it for you.

> What make cheques slow is that the bank receiving the cheque doesn't have the info to verify it. Unless you're saying in the UK you could mail a cheque to your own bank to get money transferred? I didn't think it worked like that.

And isn't exactly the same true for your "acceptgiro"? Unless you take it to a cashier, and they verify your identity, how do they know they know the pay*er*s account is genuine (as in, somebody isn't fraudulently using someone else's account to take the money out of?)

> Your example of stapling a cheque to pay-in slip makes little sense if you're submitting to your own bank. The teller can simply execute the payment on the spot.

And if I take it to the pay*ee*s bank the teller can simply execute the payment on the spot!

What we've both missed in previous comments is fraud prevention! (Me taking a signed cheque to my own branch is not proof said cheque is genuine!)

The UK's system is - and has been my entire life - symmetric. I have two pieces of paper (in your case one, your acceptgiro), that contains the payees details and the payers details. I can take them to ANY bank.

Banks now verify both the payee and payer account (which is why the Post Office won't accept cash for deposit with a hand-filled paying in slip - they can't verify it). It's usually the case that if you use and hand-filled paying in slip you have to pay in at the payee's bank, so they can check their systems and show the account exists.

Then lastly, there's the fraud aspect. Is the payment irrevocable (cash-equivalent), or revocable (cheque equivalent, is the cheque (a) genuine, and (b) authorised).

You haven't touched at all on the revocability of fraudulent transactions. What happens with your acceptgiro system if I buy your account details on the dark net, and use them to pay my bills? (Or worse, pay them into another stolen account that I can withdraw cash from?).

So the UK system is very simple. Provided I have the payer's AND the payee's account (your examples keep on forgetting one of them), I can make a payment at ANY bank. If the payment is irrevocable (cash, debit card, and the like) they will insist on verifying the payee, and the money will appear as available in the payee's account "instantly". If the payment is revocable (cheque, as far as I can tell this includes your acceptgiro), the money again appears in the payee's account "instantly", but is held in "clearing" until the payer has had a chance to see and object to the payment.

The reason our system seemed archaic is that the clearing system WAS archaic. All cheques went to a central clearing house for sorting, then they got returned to the "issuing branch" where the customer had their account, then they got checked by the branch. Nowadays, all this paperwork is scanned, and emailed to the appropriate "branch" for checking as required.

"Instantly" usually meant "next day", because the banks would send all transfers by CHAPS on 9-track tape to be processed at Central Clearing, which just happened to be physically located down the road from where I lived :-) - a mile away?

Cheers,
Wol

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Posted Mar 24, 2026 11:04 UTC (Tue) by paulj (subscriber, #341) [Link] (4 responses)

> The reason our system seemed archaic is that the clearing system WAS archaic. All cheques went to a central clearing house for sorting, then they got returned to the "issuing branch" where the customer had their account, then they got checked by the branch.

This was part of the 'innovation' of acceptgiros - it didn't just mandate the standardised slips (the user "UI") it also standardised the bank transfer system so that the giros would be reconciled fairly clearly. Even "back in the day" (e.g. 80s), a giro would clear within about 2 days. Cheques over in the Celtic isles took about a week minimum, often more (cheque reconciliation inherently requires extra steps, given the cheque goes via the payee to the payee's bank, then has to go to the payer's bank, and only /then/ can the process of the payer's bank paying the payee's start).

You keep noting that you could hand in a transfer slip to your local bank. That may be so, but... people overwhelmingly used cheques in the Celtic Isles back in the day. I assume there was a reason why payer-initiated bank transfers were not the norm, and hence I assume there was a reason why they were not better / more convenient than cheques. Possibly bank transfers were just as slow as cheques.... (??).

Either way, the normal way to pay people/businesses in the Celtic Isles - cheques - sucked back in the day, in terms of convenience and (especially speed, compared to what was the norm in the likes of NL (and perhaps other Germanic countries like DE?).

Anyway... I fear Jon is about to drag me out of LWN and eject me on to the street. ;)

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Posted Mar 24, 2026 11:26 UTC (Tue) by Wol (subscriber, #4433) [Link] (3 responses)

> This was part of the 'innovation' of acceptgiros - it didn't just mandate the standardised slips (the user "UI") it also standardised the bank transfer system so that the giros would be reconciled fairly clearly. Even "back in the day" (e.g. 80s), a giro would clear within about 2 days. Cheques over in the Celtic isles took about a week minimum, often more (cheque reconciliation inherently requires extra steps, given the cheque goes via the payee to the payee's bank, then has to go to the payer's bank, and only /then/ can the process of the payer's bank paying the payee's start).

You've just missed out "checked for fraud". Even in the 60s in the UK, it took just one day for cheques to be *reconciled* clearly. If I paid a cheque in on Monday, that money would be in the payee's bank account on Tuesday. They just couldn't touch it until the following Monday, in case it was fraudulent.

> You keep noting that you could hand in a transfer slip to your local bank. That may be so, but... people overwhelmingly used cheques in the Celtic Isles back in the day. I assume there was a reason why payer-initiated bank transfers were not the norm, and hence I assume there was a reason why they were not better / more convenient than cheques. Possibly bank transfers were just as slow as cheques.... (??).

I *guess* because the pay*ee*s systems weren't up to it? They couldn't reconcile a bank statement against their sales ledger? Or maybe because the bank statements didn't (couldn't) show a "reference" field. So the payee needed to process the cheque so they knew who had paid what bill.

> Either way, the normal way to pay people/businesses in the Celtic Isles - cheques - sucked back in the day, in terms of convenience and (especially speed, compared to what was the norm in the likes of NL (and perhaps other Germanic countries like DE?).

It sucked even compared to what was available in the UK! My bank in the 60s was the London Trustee Savings Banks, and cash(equivalent) transactions happened instantly. Likewise the Building Societies. It was only the big old banks that took 24 hours.

(Oh - and I didn't think of it, but the reason why there was no difference between going to my bank or the payee's bank, was that *validating* the cheque took place in the back office, which was quite often not the same place as the front office, so it didn't matter where a cheque entered the system they were all handled exactly the same ... it took legal changes to make the banks shorten the time before cheques were considered "cleared" and the funds available to payees.)

> Anyway... I fear Jon is about to drag me out of LWN and eject me on to the street. ;)

Ditto :-)

Cheers,
Wol

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Posted Mar 24, 2026 12:06 UTC (Tue) by paulj (subscriber, #341) [Link] (2 responses)

Hmm, I can't remember exactly what happened with cheques and where you saw the amount pending, just remember it took time to clear.

If you say the amount was posted to the payee's account quickly as a pending amount, but not available, well exactly! The payee's bank can indeed easily do that but it still took a week to complete the reconciliation (cheque -> payer's bank, payer's bank validates the cheque and debits the payer's account, payer's bank notifies payee's, payee's bank and posts the amount as a final credit to the payee). That was exactly the inefficiency. It took time.

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Posted Mar 24, 2026 12:55 UTC (Tue) by Wol (subscriber, #4433) [Link] (1 responses)

> but it still took a week to complete the reconciliation (cheque -> payer's bank, payer's bank validates the cheque and debits the payer's account, payer's bank notifies payee's, payee's bank and posts the amount as a final credit to the payee). That was exactly the inefficiency. It took time.

Except most of what you describe never happened, apart from the paper shuffling. I remember being shocked when a cheque I wrote bounced. Bear in mind I'd been banking with this bank for 15 years, when it bounced a check for £5000. Being a large amount, it set off the fraud alarms, and when the bank went to check the signature, they discovered they didn't have an official signature to check against!

All this five days, two days, whatever, was just a delay the banks built in to give the pay*er* time to spot a problem and say "this is fraudulent". The banks didn't do anything unless a transaction was suspicious in one way or another.

So this clearing delay is exactly the same sort of idea as the 24hr delay (trying to keep this post on topic :-). It provides time for the parties involved to spot a problem before the transaction becomes irreversible. But the actual transaction does go through "immediately", it just doesn't finalise until the time limit was up. (Which is just an automated "okay, five days have passed, make this money available".)

Cheers,
Wol

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Posted Mar 24, 2026 13:30 UTC (Tue) by paulj (subscriber, #341) [Link]

> Except most of what you describe never happened, apart from the paper shuffling.

It is what happened. Banks did club together to create clearing houses, to make clearing between member banks in bulk easier, and give more centralised places to clear cheques between clearing houses (e.g., Scottish banks had their own clearing house). The cheque (or an image or some form of the information aggregated into the bulk update to member bank's accounts) still did have to be reconciled by the bank itself though to finalise the transfer ("detect fraud" as you put it).

The process for clearing cheques between banks within the City of London was literally called "walks". ;)

According to this (page 21), while there was significant automation in the collation and telling of cheques, the process in England still required transferring the actual paper cheques up until 1996!

https://www.scribd.com/document/39451807/History-Publicat...

Anyway, Jon is standing here with a baseball bat, and I think we both can further just defer to histories such as the above and googling with our favourite search enginge (e.g. DDG, whatever). ;)

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Posted Mar 24, 2026 14:38 UTC (Tue) by rgmoore (✭ supporter ✭, #75) [Link] (1 responses)

And isn't exactly the same true for your "acceptgiro"? Unless you take it to a cashier, and they verify your identity, how do they know they know the pay*er*s account is genuine (as in, somebody isn't fraudulently using someone else's account to take the money out of?)

I think the idea is that your payee info and payer info are distinct, kind of like a public and private crypto key. You can publish your payee info for everyone to see, and all they can ever do with it is to give you money. You keep your payer info secret from everyone but your own bank, which has an incentive to keep it safe. That improves security.

There's also less room for someone to alter the information on the giro than there is on a check. One form of check fraud is for the payee to alter the amount of the check. That doesn't work with a giro because the payee never sees it again after sending it out. The payer could theoretically change it, but that's just like writing a check for a different amount than the invoice; the payee can refund an excess or demand complete payment. There's also less room for the payer to send the wrong amount inadvertently; they don't have to transcribe the payment amount from the bill to the giro, so there's one less place to make a mistake.

It also saves a step, at least for things like paying a bill. With a check, the payee sends the payer a bill, the payer sends the payee a check, the payee endorses the check and sends it to the bank, and the bank then clears the check. With giro, the payee can include the giro with the bill. Instead of having to send something back to the payee, the payer sends the giro straight to the bank to be cleared.

Let's stop here

Posted Mar 24, 2026 14:43 UTC (Tue) by jzb (editor, #7867) [Link]

This is way off topic, and we've asked a few times now elsewhere to end the thread. Please stop here.

Online banking via browser (was What about Play Protect?)

Posted Mar 24, 2026 15:04 UTC (Tue) by kleptog (subscriber, #1183) [Link]

> Then lastly, there's the fraud aspect. Is the payment irrevocable (cash-equivalent), or revocable (cheque equivalent, is the cheque (a) genuine, and (b) authorised).

This is getting off into the weeds, but you couldn't transfer to any account. The organisation asking for payment pre-printed the amount, their bank account details and reference numbers. They often also preprinted your name and account details so the only thing you had to do was sign it. The printing of acceptgiros was strictly regulated with all sorts of checks.

That said, fraud did happen, just like with cheques. You got your money back in that case.

It's all theoretical now, since they were abolished a few years ago due to lack of use, having been replaced by digital payment methods (e.g. iDeal).


Copyright © 2026, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds