Wtf
Wtf
Posted Mar 20, 2026 13:12 UTC (Fri) by higuita (subscriber, #32245)In reply to: Wtf by mb
Parent article: Google details new 24-hour process to sideload unverified Android apps (Ars Technica)
There is a real security need to make side-loading less easy, non-tech savy people can install apps without understanding what they are doing.... but google also is being pushed to open the store and they don't want that. Joining both was perfect for google, can give from one side and take from another!
Now imagine that google didn't also wanted to control the app install, just solve the security problem... just this alone is a hard problem, just warnings do not work, people ignore them, specially if they are under pressure and the other side say "it is ok, just press ok". i would imagine some possible solutions (layers, not one solves all):
- name and icon. this is perfect for AI, if its name is too similar to any existent app. Block if too similar. may require existent apps to actually be renamed as this problem exist already in google store
- no app install during calls
- store signature, each apk need a store signature and yes, google can keep track of valid stores... but also allow say a EU signature repo, japan/south korea or even china repos, to avoid google totally blocking a store by US gov order. user can choose to enable or not other signature repos. This allow brands to have their own app stores too. User can choose also to override trust in any signature (say i want to forbid google signatures, but allow fdroid)
- no side-load without a valid store (ie: allow third party store, but they require above store signatures), except below rules
- adb sideload always possible, mostly for devs
- new key signature load via adb possible
- do not see any way to allow user-enabled side-load that can't be abused, even the 24h delay can be abused with "(call me/i will call you) tomorrow", so the push should be to move the side-load to third party stores and adb requirement as less likely to be mass abused
The LWN site is currently under high scraper load, so comment display has been suppressed for anonymous users. If you are a human, you may read the comments by clicking the button below:
Note: you can avoid this step in the future by logging into your LWN account.
