|
|
Log in / Subscribe / Register

Wtf

Wtf

Posted Mar 20, 2026 4:22 UTC (Fri) by rsidd (subscriber, #2582)
In reply to: Wtf by linuxrocks123
Parent article: Google details new 24-hour process to sideload unverified Android apps (Ars Technica)

Many educated and well-off people in India have fallen to an absurd scam called a "digital arrest". The government has tried to send messages to all mobile users, via SMS etc, that there is no such thing as a digital arrest. Media have extensively covered such scams. Despite that, when told that they are under "digital arrest" and asked to sit in front of their computer or phone with their camera on for hours, people have done that. Because the trust in police is very low, awareness of rights is even lower, and bullshit detection sense almost non-existent.

Anyway, yes, malware scams are common too.


to post comments

Wtf

Posted Mar 20, 2026 8:15 UTC (Fri) by gspr (subscriber, #91542) [Link] (12 responses)

> Because the trust in police is very low,

I'm sorry, but I don't follow how low trust in an institution increases the likelihood of imposters pretending to be that institution being followed blindly. You'd think it would be the opposite, no? That in countries where people do trust the police, they'd be more likely to believe that the police want you to sit still in front of your computer?

> awareness of rights is even lower, and bullshit detection sense almost non-existent.

This is obviously a serious problem, and I don't mean to mock it, but: is a *technical* solution really what's needed here? Even disregarding the hundreds of millions who needlessly gets the technical solution forced upon them – is it not incredibly patronizing for a tech company to try to patch over a serious societal issue by treating the members of that society as a danger to themselves? As incapable of owning their own devices without sleeping on it first?

Low trust increasing the chance of obeying an impostor

Posted Mar 20, 2026 9:05 UTC (Fri) by farnz (subscriber, #17727) [Link] (2 responses)

In a country with high trust in the institution of the police, you know that if it was an actual officer ordering you to sit still in front of the computer, the worst case outcome from calling the local equivalent of 911 and asking if you can stop now is someone telling you that it was a legitimate demand from an officer, not a crime, and the best case is being told to stop doing it and someone coming out to talk to you with a view to investigating the officer in question.

Similarly, if you disobey the officer by walking into a manned police station, and ask to be put in their cells for the arrest period, the worst that happens is that they put you in their cells, and the best case is that they laugh and tell you that there's no such thing as a digital arrest and you walk out free.

In a country with low trust, you expect the worst case to be the emergency operator notifying the police that you've questioned their authority, and thus getting you into more trouble - maybe a beating, maybe a further arrest, and the best case is that you're told to just respect the police's authority and do as you're told. Worse, you also expect that if you disobey the officer, you'll get a beating, or if you go to the police station, they'll give you a beating for being dumb enough to believe the lie - or even arrest you properly "to teach you not to waste their time".

Low trust increasing the chance of obeying an impostor

Posted Mar 20, 2026 9:34 UTC (Fri) by gspr (subscriber, #91542) [Link] (1 responses)

These are fair points. But to me, it sounds more like they're pertaining to a *corrupt* police force, rather than one that enjoys little trust from society. Of course, the former may be a reason for the latter – but the actual problem is that the police are corrupt and might beat you for checking their identity, not that you felt the need to check their identity in the first place.

Low trust increasing the chance of obeying an impostor

Posted Mar 23, 2026 9:01 UTC (Mon) by MarkVandenBorre (subscriber, #26071) [Link]

The nuance is slightly different and broader. The powers that be are untouchable and unaccountable, or at least perceived to be so. In a low trust society, you are trained to not look for trouble by interacting with these forces as little as possible. They often bite ruthlessly before they bark.

The closest analogy I have found in my native generally high trust Belgium is being forced to deal with the tax authorities. "Oh, but I've done everything right." Yes, but they can still make your life miserable because they don't believe you. They can bury you in procedural load. They will find some arcane requirement you haven't followed to the letter. Etcetera.

Lack of trust and the resulting lack of communication. That is often a very effective attack vector for scammers.

Wtf

Posted Mar 20, 2026 11:19 UTC (Fri) by NAR (subscriber, #1313) [Link] (8 responses)

Even disregarding the hundreds of millions who needlessly gets the technical solution forced upon them – is it not incredibly patronizing for a tech company to try to patch over a serious societal issue by treating the members of that society as a danger to themselves? As incapable of owning their own devices without sleeping on it first?

I doubt there are hundreds of millions users out there who want to install applications outside from Google Play. On the other hand I've just read that one in six(!) bank consumers got scammed and lost money in my country. I am somewhat skeptical about this number, because I don't know anyone personally who got successfully scammed - on the other hand it's not something people are boasting about. There are definitely hundreds of millions people out that who can be easily scammed. Also I see bank implementing delays in transfers - it's a big enough problem to do something about it.

This the very same reason why we have two factor authentication nowadays everywhere - it's fairly easy to trick passwords out of people. My mother told her password to a scammer, thankfully they couldn't login to the bank account. Also, after she put down the phone, she called me immediately - outside of the high pressure situation created by the scammer she could reason clearly and notice that something is wrong.

Wtf

Posted Mar 20, 2026 11:43 UTC (Fri) by mb (subscriber, #50428) [Link] (7 responses)

>one in six(!) bank consumers got scammed

With the use of sideloading?
Yes, many many crimes happen. But unless these can be prevented by restricting sideloading, this is off topic.

Wtf

Posted Mar 20, 2026 12:54 UTC (Fri) by NAR (subscriber, #1313) [Link]

There were no details in the article I've read, but one case study I did read involved a key logger installed ("sideloaded") on the victim's computer. It was a couple of years ago, before most of the online banking was moved to apps.

Wtf

Posted Mar 20, 2026 13:12 UTC (Fri) by higuita (subscriber, #32245) [Link] (5 responses)

in case you still didn't understand, this is a needed security feature that is perfect to help protect google store profits... just like age verification is great way for facebook track you... but it would not be accepted if sold like that, so it is sold as protect kids

There is a real security need to make side-loading less easy, non-tech savy people can install apps without understanding what they are doing.... but google also is being pushed to open the store and they don't want that. Joining both was perfect for google, can give from one side and take from another!

Now imagine that google didn't also wanted to control the app install, just solve the security problem... just this alone is a hard problem, just warnings do not work, people ignore them, specially if they are under pressure and the other side say "it is ok, just press ok". i would imagine some possible solutions (layers, not one solves all):
- name and icon. this is perfect for AI, if its name is too similar to any existent app. Block if too similar. may require existent apps to actually be renamed as this problem exist already in google store
- no app install during calls
- store signature, each apk need a store signature and yes, google can keep track of valid stores... but also allow say a EU signature repo, japan/south korea or even china repos, to avoid google totally blocking a store by US gov order. user can choose to enable or not other signature repos. This allow brands to have their own app stores too. User can choose also to override trust in any signature (say i want to forbid google signatures, but allow fdroid)
- no side-load without a valid store (ie: allow third party store, but they require above store signatures), except below rules
- adb sideload always possible, mostly for devs
- new key signature load via adb possible
- do not see any way to allow user-enabled side-load that can't be abused, even the 24h delay can be abused with "(call me/i will call you) tomorrow", so the push should be to move the side-load to third party stores and adb requirement as less likely to be mass abused

Wtf

Posted Mar 20, 2026 15:10 UTC (Fri) by intelfx (subscriber, #130118) [Link] (4 responses)

> this is a needed security feature that is perfect to help protect google store profits

This wording was perhaps unintended on your part, but it is in fact brilliant. This is a much-needed security feature, where the thing being secured is Google's profits :-)

Wtf

Posted Mar 20, 2026 16:21 UTC (Fri) by malmedal (subscriber, #56172) [Link] (3 responses)

What's the argument you're making, exactly?

Are you saying the change will not reduce the number of people being scammed?

Are you saying it will help Google and therefore it shouldn't be done regardless of utility?

Something else?

A time-based lockout is not a new idea. It has been successfully used since before computers were invented.

Wtf

Posted Mar 20, 2026 17:12 UTC (Fri) by intelfx (subscriber, #130118) [Link] (2 responses)

> Are you saying <...>

I am saying that "Think of the victims" is the "Think of the children" 2.0. If that doesn't explain it to you, I'm not quite certain what will.

In any case, it is fundamentally pointless to argue with people intent on not seeing the obvious, and I'm not going to waste my time doing that.

Wtf

Posted Mar 20, 2026 17:41 UTC (Fri) by malmedal (subscriber, #56172) [Link]

> "Think of the victims" is the "Think of the children" 2.0

Some of those actually did help, others did not, some even made it worse.

In all cases there would be somebody screaming NO NO NO.

Wtf

Posted Mar 20, 2026 17:56 UTC (Fri) by Cyberax (✭ supporter ✭, #52523) [Link]

Have you considered that some changes might be good overall, even if they are made for less-than-generous reasons? And vice versa.


Copyright © 2026, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds