|
|
Log in / Subscribe / Register

Images are a false simplification

Images are a false simplification

Posted Nov 7, 2025 16:10 UTC (Fri) by pizza (subscriber, #46)
In reply to: Images are a false simplification by dottedmag
Parent article: A security model for systemd

> I'm saying "be aware, authors' knowledge in at least some areas related to software engineering is very limited".

That doesn't follow. Their [un]willingness to adhere to "best practices of software engineering" does not mean they lack knowledge -- the far more likely explanation is that they are not willing (or able) to undertake the extra (on an ongoing basis) workload without some sort of compensation.


to post comments

Images are a false simplification

Posted Nov 7, 2025 16:26 UTC (Fri) by farnz (subscriber, #17727) [Link] (7 responses)

In turn, that means it's reasonable to avoid their work product if they're not willing to do the work you want them to do.

You have no right to demand that they do the work; at best, you can ask nicely and see if they'd come to a mutually agreeable arrangement to do the work, but they have no right to demand that you use their software.

However, they have no right to insist that you use their work product, either; it may inconvenience you to not use it, but you can always find or make an alternative that does meet your standards.

Note that regulation can change this balance (e.g. by requiring them to meet certain standards if conditions are met), but that's the default position absent a specific regulation.

Images are a false simplification

Posted Nov 7, 2025 17:12 UTC (Fri) by pizza (subscriber, #46) [Link] (6 responses)

> However, they have no right to insist that you use their work product, either; it may inconvenience you to not use it, but you can always find or make an alternative that does meet your standards.

I'm reminded of this essay:

https://caddy.community/t/the-realities-of-being-a-foss-m...

"I do find it ironic that the open source community is so irate about having to compile software from source to customize it the way they want."

Best parts of the Caddy essay

Posted Nov 7, 2025 23:18 UTC (Fri) by farnz (subscriber, #17727) [Link] (5 responses)

The entitlement section of that essay is significant, and the following (from the "Emotional Manipulation" section) is probably the most significant quote you can pull from the essay:
Here’s the brutal truth for 99.9% (* not an actual figure) of open source projects, folks: you (the user of an open source project) need and rely on the project more than the maintainers do.

Best parts of the Caddy essay

Posted Nov 8, 2025 7:02 UTC (Sat) by dottedmag (subscriber, #18590) [Link] (4 responses)

Is it? I personally find it puzzling that "let's make maintainers do something" argument even came up in this thread, I thought it's all discussed and agreed long time ago that authors owe nothing to whoever uses their product (heck, this is written on the can from the very beginning).

I understand some people may be burned by it and see it in every shadow, but read again and you'll see nobody proposed pushing authors to do anything.

Best parts of the Caddy essay

Posted Nov 9, 2025 13:22 UTC (Sun) by farnz (subscriber, #17727) [Link] (3 responses)

I think it is, because the reply to you that triggered this subthread amounts to "upstream owes me support for their code in a form I'm willing to accept", just phrased differently.

And this is a problem because it implies that the comment author has internalised the idea that "open source" means "free labour", even if they wouldn't ever claim that consciously - and even if they'd fight back at the idea that open source maintainers owe them anything.

Best parts of the Caddy essay

Posted Nov 11, 2025 16:08 UTC (Tue) by nye (guest, #51576) [Link] (2 responses)

> I think it is, because the reply to you that triggered this subthread amounts to "upstream owes me support for their code in a form I'm willing to accept", just phrased differently.

I really don't agree that "stay away from X" is another way of phrasing "X owes me support".

Best parts of the Caddy essay

Posted Nov 11, 2025 16:13 UTC (Tue) by dottedmag (subscriber, #18590) [Link] (1 responses)

Of course. Because it is not.

Come on people, what the hell is wrong with the community that "open source authors owe me anything" comes up in every discussion that has nothing to do with it? Is it really that bad nowadays? My last experience leading open source project was in 2010, has the scene changed that dramatically that everyone is now burned out?

Best parts of the Caddy essay

Posted Nov 11, 2025 17:21 UTC (Tue) by pizza (subscriber, #46) [Link]

> Is it really that bad nowadays? My last experience leading open source project was in 2010, has the scene changed that dramatically that everyone is now burned out?

In a word... yes. And also yes.


Copyright © 2026, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds