Images are a false simplification
Images are a false simplification
Posted Nov 6, 2025 19:01 UTC (Thu) by Nahor (subscriber, #51583)In reply to: Images are a false simplification by nim-nim
Parent article: A security model for systemd
Nobody said that signatures are the only thing needed, that they are sufficient. We only said that they are necessary. You still need someone to verify that what is being signed is what it's supposed to be. And you're only supposed to accept the signature of people you trust (be it a vendor, a regulator, a consumer association, whatever).
On their own, yes, signatures are useless. But so is source code verification if you have no way to ensure that your binaries are built from that code, by a compiler that will not add backdoors, and that the loader/kernel is actually loading that binary when executing.
One without the other is useless. Individually, they are both necessary but insufficient. It's only when they are combined that they become sufficient.
And signatures is what allows you to choose who to trust instead of blindly trusting a vendor. If you trust a consumer association and they have signed off on some regulators. Then you can trust that those regulators are doing their job. And if those regulators signed off on a vendor, then you can trust that the vendor is doing the right thing.
> it is the usual ending of let’s trust the vendor initiatives
Which is better than "let's trust the vendor and trust that no random person is going to change the box".
