Practical use of LLMs
Practical use of LLMs
Posted Aug 29, 2025 15:04 UTC (Fri) by Wol (subscriber, #4433)In reply to: Practical use of LLMs by jepsis
Parent article: On the use of LLM assistants for kernel development
> LLMs are not so strong for programming,
Programming is very much a language-related task. So which is it, LLMs are particularly effective for programming, or LLMs are useless at language? You can't have it both ways!
And has been pointed out, LLMs are very capable at chucking out text that is simultaneously extremely plausible, and complete bullshit. THAT is the problem.
The problem we want to solve isn't language, it's communication. And with absolutely no concept of comprehension or truth, LLMs are a serious liability.
That said, LLMs are good at cleaning text up round the edges - until this eager-beaverness of all the peddlers of this rubbish actually gets seriously in the way of actually doing what you want to! I'm sick to death of Acrobat's desperation to "Let me summarise this document for you", when I'm actually looking for the *detail* I need which a summary will pretty much inevitably remove. The same with Sheets and Gemini - if I need detail to solve a problem, the LAST thing I need is Artificial Idiocy trying to summarise what I'm looking at!
Cheers,
Wol
