|
|
Log in / Subscribe / Register

Speech opportunity.

Speech opportunity.

Posted Jan 30, 2025 1:57 UTC (Thu) by Heretic_Blacksheep (guest, #169992)
In reply to: Speech opportunity. by ballombe
Parent article: FOSDEM keynote causes concerns

I'd argue that if Dorsey's speech had been less self congratulatory on the surface and more about the financial end of getting open source funded and its potential gotchas it would have been more on point for community oriented FOSS conferences like FOSDEM. FOSDEM is more about social networking and increasing the visibility of small projects or hard problems and solutions that may benefit wider audiences irrespective of corporate or government interests. One of those hard problems is financial backing.

That's not how the speech title comes across. To me, Dorsey was intending to talk about exploitation of open source concepts and work product in the typical corporate speak: free labor and ideas from the commons for a better bottom line. This makes it inappropriate for any grass roots open source conference and more appropriate for astroturfed corporate cheer leading conferences.

So to me, the Spacecake comment was definitely over the top and rightfully moderated, while friendlysock was using one of the many tropes detractors use to derail criticism they don't like (throwing insults trope). It's not that friendlysock is missing the point, they're actively trying to derail criticism.


to post comments

Speech opportunity.

Posted Jan 30, 2025 3:17 UTC (Thu) by intelfx (subscriber, #130118) [Link] (1 responses)

> friendlysock was using one of the many tropes detractors use to derail criticism they don't like (throwing insults trope). It's not that friendlysock is missing the point, they're actively trying to derail criticism.

Criticism of criticism is strictly as valid as the original one. Also, I see no insults in this quote.

I'm not defending Dorsey, but it is disingenuous to label everything you disagree with as "derailment" and downplay opposing viewpoints as something "they don't like".

Speech opportunity.

Posted Feb 2, 2025 22:42 UTC (Sun) by ghodgkins (subscriber, #157257) [Link]

Re insults, I would guess Heretic_Blacksheep was referring to the phrase "hurr durr," which when used in a quote implies (at best) that the quoted speaker is a "stereotypical idiot."

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/hurr_durr


Copyright © 2026, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds