LILO vs. GRUB
Posted Jun 17, 2004 3:43 UTC (Thu) by jreiser
Parent article: LILO vs. GRUB
LILO stores information about the location of the kernel or other operating system on the Master Boot Record (MBR).
GRUB often stores its own program in "no mans's land": the remaining sectors of the first track. Usually this is LBA sectors 1 through 63 (31.5KB). This is exactly the place to get clobbered by Cedilla or other dreck associated with MS Wind*ws, and there were more than a few multi-booting users in the US whose Linux became disabled when they installed Intuit's TurboTax 2002. Some storage media have many fewer sectors on the first track, and any disk can have a partition table that puts those sectors inside a partition; GRUB will have a hard time on such a device.
It is possible to write an MBR+ext2 bootloader for x86 that boots a kernel and initrd by name lookup in the root filesystem, and resides entirely in the (512-64-n) bytes of the MBR plus the 1KB boot block of a minimal ext2/ext3 filesystem. See http://www.BitWagon.com/ftp/mbr03.tgz and http://www.BitWagon.com/ftp/e2boot4c.tgz.
[Note that e2boot4c is for 1KB blocks, and requires modification for 4KB blocks. Also, this work was done in 1998 and does not observe the Extended BIOS Data Area below 0xA0000.]
to post comments)