LWN.net Logo

From code war to Cold War (BBC)

From code war to Cold War (BBC)

Posted Mar 8, 2004 16:51 UTC (Mon) by ccchips (subscriber, #3222)
Parent article: From code war to Cold War (BBC)

Let's put it this way:

I have some software at home that I use for composing music. It's proprietary. The company has gone out of business. *Some* of the pieces wound up in another company's product, but effectively, the product no longer exists in the form which I have been using.

There are things about this piece of software that are broken. There are things that become less and less effective as the underlying OS changes. Yet, there is absloutely *no way* for me to improve, restore, repair, or otherwise modernize this piece of work.

If the software had been "copy-protected," I also would be unable to restore its operation in the event of a magnetic media failure (a common occurrence.)

I view this state of affairs as pathetic. If the best solution available is to mandate escrow of all commercial source code, that's fine with me.

I had a range-hood in my kitchen. The chimney for that range-hood was toward the right of the stove. When I bought a new hood (because the old one was useless, dirty, badly damaged, and so on,) the installer refused to put it in because the chimney was in the wrong place. I hired a metal-worker to modify the chimney, and now I have a working range hood. I didn't have to beg the hood maker, nor my house builder, nor the duct-manufacturer, nor anyone else for permission to make this improvement.

In fact, I could have maybe even restored the original range hood (except it didn't fit our decor.)

When the same sort of freedom arrives in the computer industry, I'll know we've arrived where I'd like to be.


(Log in to post comments)

My solution

Posted Mar 9, 2004 2:01 UTC (Tue) by dmaxwell (guest, #14010) [Link]

I do not store any data I intend to keep long term in closed formats. That means mp3 or ogg in preference to wma. It means Openoffice or even plain text in preference to Word and so on. Yes, I know mp3 is patent encumbered; how it works is not a secret. The worst thing that can happen is that I'll have to give up a favored application and use something else to open my data. To the extent it is possible, I use FOSS apps to create and manipulate data since the shelf life of an app in source code form is higher. If I have to sacrifice features for longevity then so be it. This is a trust issue and I don't trust closed software.

In the case of your music software, if you hypothetically saved your music as .mid rather than some closed UltraComposer format at least you can still work with it using something else.

Copyright © 2012, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds