LWN.net Logo

Now it's available to non-subscribers ...

Now it's available to non-subscribers ...

Posted Nov 27, 2003 14:13 UTC (Thu) by Wol (guest, #4433)
Parent article: On comment abuse

As a non-subscriber, I would go for the toggle that says "view subscriber-only / all comments".

And if you do stop non-subscribers posting, PLEASE don't make the letters page subscriber only!

What you need to watch out for here is that you may drive non-subscribers away. You need to attract them and persuade them to subscribe, not drive them away so that your "fringe" readership declines, and your core declines with it ...

Cheers,
Wol


(Log in to post comments)

Now it's available to non-subscribers ...

Posted Nov 27, 2003 19:02 UTC (Thu) by iksrazal (guest, #5184) [Link]

"What you need to watch out for here is that you may drive non-subscribers away. You need to attract them and persuade them to subscribe, not drive them away so that your "fringe" readership declines, and your core declines with it ..."

Unfortunately, I doubt very many people who feel passionately about eliminating non-subscriber comments actually will read that. LWN is a great service - I've read it for about 4 years - and I'm happy that they have found a way to be healthy.

However, I live in brazil - a third world country. It happens to have excellent programmers - many who contribute or even maintain the kernel. Yet the currency Real is about 3 to 1 dollar at the moment, making it 3 times more of a committment to support LWN.

I understand trolls are a problem here and everywhere. Also, I rarely post. But LWN would be yet another place lost in an increasingly commercial linux landscape - forgetting some who helped get us to where we are. That hasn't happened here - yet.

A suggestion: a several week waiting period before non-subscibers could post after getting a login. It might deter those who require an instant gratification to create problems.

iksrazal

Copyright © 2013, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds