LWN.net Logo

Here come the copyright vigilantes

For a view into just how weird our world is becoming, have a look at this News.com article by Declan McCullagh. Mr. McCullagh got a chance to read a draft law by U.S. Representatives Howard Berman and Howard Coble that would legalize attacks against P2P networks:

The legislation would immunize groups such as the Motion Picture Association of America and the Recording Industry Association of America from all state and federal laws if they disable, block or otherwise impair a "publicly accessible peer-to-peer network." Anyone whose computer was damaged in the process must receive the permission of the U.S. attorney general before filing a lawsuit, and a suit could be filed only if the actual monetary loss was more than $250.

This is worth stating again: somebody who claims that you might be violating their copyright will be legally allowed to attack your systems. You can not challenge the attacker in court without getting permission from a federal bureaucrat - who, one assumes, may not be particularly sympathetic to your cause.

For added fun, any "copyright holder" will be authorized to act in this fashion. As soon as, say, a copyrighted article is posted to Usenet, the owner of that article will have the right to take the whole thing down. If one makes the reasonable assumption that some people might just feel the need to retaliate against an attack of this nature, whether or not they are protected by federal law, it is not hard to foresee a time when the net is a rather more violent and unpleasant place than it is now.

It is hard to imagine this law actually passing - though it is dangerous to assume reasonable behavior in Washington these days. But the proposal is a clear sign of the sort of power grab that is underway. Not only do they want control over every bit that passes through your computer; they also want the ability to take justice into their own hands if they don't like your behavior. Stallman's The Right To Read looks more prophetic all the time.


(Log in to post comments)

Here come the copyright vigilantes

Posted Jul 25, 2002 7:04 UTC (Thu) by gedeco (guest, #1323) [Link]

Looks really like a lot of fun to me.
If they bring one of my servers down, I will persuit them according the laws in my country, where the attacked server is located.
If I prove loss of data, the lawyers of my country will decide they have to pay me back. If not, goods of the company in question, who are in my country, will be confiscated.
Another assumption: 10 servers brought down by an attack could mean 10 counterattacks. Balance: 1 against 10.

Who said real life is better then a computer game?
This really looks like fun to me.

Serious now, this is one of the most silly laws I ever heard.
Ever heard of the bommerang effect? They will find out.
The impact would be global and not restricted to one country with silly lawyers. It should be a start of a gobal internet war.

Here come the copyright vigilantes

Posted Jul 25, 2002 14:12 UTC (Thu) by bibliophile (guest, #1766) [Link]

Wait a sec... Does this mean that a "black hat", suspecting a company of distributing some of his copyrighted materials, can legally hack it? I see a new wave of virii spreading p2p clients....

Silly bunts.

Copyright © 2002, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds