LWN.net Logo

Distribution quotes of the week

Distribution quotes of the week

Posted Dec 9, 2012 10:34 UTC (Sun) by yeti-dn (guest, #46560)
In reply to: Distribution quotes of the week by tpo
Parent article: Distribution quotes of the week

Five years are about the edge for a desktop system. Both in the sense that it is doable since things are starting to fall apart but the technologies have not diverged too far yet and it may be still acceptable for conservative users.

Please go and read the actual conditions for RHEL. The later stages and extended support are clearly meant to just keep installed systems running. You get no new features, no support for newer hardware, services, file formats, etc. This is fine for a server that has a dedicated task to do. It is also fine for a single-purpose user machine, for instance used to control an instrument where you do not want, ideally, any changes at all (hence, little support). But this discussion started about desktop distros. And for a desktop (as in general purpose user system), not being able to connect most hardware newer than 10 years old, open any file formats that have appeared or changed substantially in last 10 years, use various services due to too ancient clients, ..., is deadly.

Also note you pay rather a lot for RHEL support -- fixing security holes in ten years old programs is terribly ungrateful work. Since community distros cannot make the contributors do it, those that tried to introduce this kind of long term support have all failed.


(Log in to post comments)

Distribution quotes of the week

Posted Dec 9, 2012 17:46 UTC (Sun) by raven667 (subscriber, #5198) [Link]

But let's be clear, the extended support kicks in at the end of life, a life that does include feature updates so you'd have to count from the end of feature updates, not from the beginning ship date. Also, CentOS for those who aren't going to pay. In any event, as you say, the refresh rate for desktops is 5yrs or so which would bring new versions of the supported enterprise-style OS, one like RHEL which is highly backwards compatible with previous releases

Copyright © 2013, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds