Weekly edition Kernel Security Distributions Contact Us Search Archives Calendar Subscribe Write for LWN LWN.net FAQ Sponsors

# Good piece

## Good piece

Posted Nov 29, 2012 21:36 UTC (Thu) by Cyberax (✭ supporter ✭, #52523)
In reply to: Good piece by davidescott
Parent article: LCE: Don't play dice with random numbers

>Again you aren't talking about Classical Mechanics. Your Demon wants to predict what will happen to the ball at time t_2, and wants to make that prediction based on the state of the universe at time t_0.
Yup.

>Suppose that the correct prediction is "the ball does not exist at time t_2, because an Invader appears at time t_1 \in (t_0, t_2) and vaporizes the ball before t_2." If your Demon is capable of making such a prediction then he/she must be able to
It must be able to integrate equations of motion. That's all.

>Express in the notation of classical Newtonian mechanics the position and velocity of the Space Invader at time t_0, so that I can deterministically show that the invader MUST begin to slow at time t_1 and destroy the ball prior to time t_2.
Wrong. "Space invader" exists only at ONE point - it has infinite speed and can't slow down.

>You CANNOT do so because v=infinity and x=everywhere (or x=emptyset) is not a valid expression of position and velocity of a body in Newtonian Mechanics. In Newton's formulas, the infinitely fast object DOES NOT EXIST within the classical universe, but his formulas allow it to be the finite-time limit of a classical process.
Newtonian mechanics has no problems with infinitely fast objects, as long as you don't collide them with something else.

That makes them a little bit like black holes - they are singularities, but they are fairly well-behaved

Good piece

Posted Nov 29, 2012 23:21 UTC (Thu) by davidescott (guest, #58580) [Link]

> Newtonian mechanics has no problems with infinitely fast objects, as long as you don't collide them with something else.

WHAT?

If you think that is the case solve the following single particle 1-dimensional, force-less system:
t=0: the particle is "at" x=0 and has dx/dt=\infty and d^2x/dt^2=0.
Solve for t=1 to get x_1,v_1,a_1

Now solve the following systems for t=1 and t=-1:
t=0: x=x_1, dx/dt=-v_1, d^2x/dt^2=a_1
t=0: x=2*x_1, dx/dt=-v_1, d^2x/dt^2=a_1
t=0: x=x_1, dx/dt=-2*v_1, d^2x/dt^2=a_1
t=0: x=2*x_1, dx/dt=-2*v_1, d^2x/dt^2=a_1

Either you cannot do this, or something will be contradictory.

Good piece

Posted Nov 30, 2012 0:33 UTC (Fri) by Cyberax (✭ supporter ✭, #52523) [Link]

That's just an artifact of a chosen coordinate system. If you really want to solve it - write down Lagrangian of a system and see what happens.

Good piece

Posted Nov 30, 2012 2:18 UTC (Fri) by davidescott (guest, #58580) [Link]

I'm telling you I can't solve that. I don't know how. If you think it is so easily solved I would love to see your solution.