LWN.net Logo

Advertisement

GStreamer, Embedded Linux, Android, VoD, Smooth Streaming, DRM, RTSP, HEVC, PulseAudio, OpenGL. Register now to attend.

Advertise here

Preparing the kernel for UEFI secure boot

Preparing the kernel for UEFI secure boot

Posted Sep 11, 2012 11:21 UTC (Tue) by jpfrancois (subscriber, #65948)
In reply to: Preparing the kernel for UEFI secure boot by intgr
Parent article: Preparing the kernel for UEFI secure boot

This is not the cost of mainlining, but :
overlap with existing driver.
inclusion of features that do not belong in the hardware.

For instance, I doubt you could convince a V4L2 maintainer that a driver doing BGGR to UYVY (ie format conversion) inside the driver is appropriate, and they would be right, this is not a good technical solution, the right thing to do is do the postprocessing in userspace.

However we have a customer with a lot of existing code using UYVY format, and for some reason, they don't think they can introduce soft debayering in these existing tools. So we provide a hack that as legitimately no place in mainline

Even without this unusual use case, not an option does not mean "won't be accepeted in mainline" but not interesting because :
-not flexible enough
-time to market (and time to bugfix / new feature)
-uncertain cost / benefice ratio.

In fact, distro balkanization is a problem that can be easily avoided by distributing the source instead of the binary. UEFI is potentially a huge hurdle to module source distribution. However according to M Garett :

"We're planning on using Suse's approach of permitting local key management at the shim level, and I spent some time discussing this with Vojtech last week. In combination with the above, this should provide a workable mechanism for permitting the end-user to install module signing keys. "

So it seems out of tree module will remain a possibility.


(Log in to post comments)

Copyright © 2013, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds