LWN.net Logo

Princess Nell

Princess Nell

Posted Apr 8, 2012 13:06 UTC (Sun) by mstone (subscriber, #58824)
In reply to: Princess Nell by tialaramex
Parent article: A report from the Peru OLPC deployment

> It's a frustratingly familiar structure for Stephenson.

It's a frustratingly familiar reality (CDC report, WHO report) that we are also working slowly but steadily in our own small ways to fix.

> Giving deprived children a networked computer is not step one.

Two thoughts:

  1. With problems of this size, there may be no single "step one"; instead, there is your step one and my step one, hopefully followed by our step two.

  2. Actually, giving kids powerful things to think with seems like a pretty darn reasonable place to start to me...


(Log in to post comments)

Princess Nell

Posted Apr 9, 2012 5:36 UTC (Mon) by filteredperception (guest, #5692) [Link]

"
> It's a frustratingly familiar structure for Stephenson.

It's a frustratingly familiar reality (CDC report, WHO report) that we are also working slowly but steadily in our own small ways to fix.
"

Since I started the dig, I'll clarify- I have no problem with fictionalized rape, for these reasons, playing a large role in a lot of novels. But having it done to the _main protagonistsa_ in a bildungsroman/child-to-adult-growth-epic, without blatant foreshadowing, i.e. as a shocking ending, is what I object to in a catcher-in-the-rye critique sort of way. I'm deluded enough to have written my own scifi novel where the protagonist gets skullf'd by Dick Cheney, but I mention it in chapter 1, so that readers can just toss the book asside if thats not their thing. Having Stephenson, such an A+++ author throw that in, only at the end, after a truly amazing and prophetic, and intelligent novel about nanotechnology, written in 1993-ish just ticked me off a bit. Of course there is the chinese judge torturing a character named phyrefox to get his information about the elusive CryptNet in the beginning, but still- raping your protagonista shockingly at the end of a long, great tech-fiction book... eh.... Seemed like something I'd only do after being tortured by the Chinese government into writing a totalitarian-apologist novel with the theme that protecting your daughter from the oncoming uneducated horde is a good reason to discard democratic free-speech in favor of a social contract heavy on a foundation of state sponsored torture.

Princess Nell

Posted Apr 13, 2012 16:24 UTC (Fri) by cdmiller (subscriber, #2813) [Link]

Interestingly Friday, by Heinlein, begins with the protaganista rape, although she's past or at the end of her bildungsroman stage.

Copyright © 2013, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds