Debian Edu is one of the
quiet success stories of free software. If you are North American, you
might have barely heard of it. Depending on what country you are in, you
might know it better as Skolelinux. Or perhaps you have heard of
Extremadura, an autonomous region of Spain that has deployed tens of
thousands installations of LinEx, which is a Skolelinux partner. Under all these names, Debian Edu has worked for almost eleven years building a totally free-licensed distribution that balances the demands of complex hardware configurations with the educational needs of children.
Debian Edu began with two projects founded in 2001: Debian Edu, founded by
Raphaël Hertzog in France, and Skolelinux, founded by a group of
Norwegian developers. The projects merged in 2006, and today Debian Edu is
technically used for the project name and Skolelinux for the distribution, although in practice the names are used interchangeably according to personal preference and previous regional branding.
The goals of Debian Edu are unchanged from when the two initial projects
began. According to Petter Reinholdtsen, one of Skolelinux's founders, they
are to educate school children while using free software that supports each
student's native languages. Debian was chosen as the base distribution
because it was known to have a package to create installation CDs — a
rare feature, back then. Similarly, thin clients were supported first because Ragnar Wisløf, another Skolelinux founder, was familiar with the Linux Terminal Server Project (LTSP), which seemed a good match for the older hardware often found at schools.
"Later," Reinholdtsen said, "we added support for network booted workstations with all software running locally but without a local disk, providing a powerful desktop without any local maintenance."
Today the project is funded regularly by its legal entity, SLX Debian Labs Foundation, which is also the majority owner of Skolelinux Drift AS, a company that provides commercial support for schools and municipalities. In the past, the project has also received funding from other sources, including the Norwegian Ministry of Education and Ministry of Reform and Administration.
Currently, Debian Edu has an active group of about ten developers, and an
unknown number of translators and other contributors. A member association,
Fri Programvare i Skolen organizes developer meetings and promotes the
project. The project also works with Edubuntu, particularly on the LTSP project, and has some contact with similar projects in Brazil and other parts of the world, although "not as much as I would wish," Reinholdtsen added.
As with most free software projects, accurate installation numbers are impossible to find. However, Reinholdtsen calculated that a minimum of 120 schools use Skolelinux in Norway alone. Other large communities of users are in France and Germany, and some are known to exist in Japan and Taiwan as well.
Installation and documentation
Skolelinux uses the standard Debian installer, lightly rebranded and with a few additions. Contrary to the still-surviving myth, this installer is no longer much of a challenge to use, although it still offers more choices than the installation programs of most major distributions. In fact, according to Reinholdtsen, Debian Edu helped to fund Joey Hess's extensive rewriting of the Debian installer a few years ago.
All the same, Skolelinux is unusual enough that users should read the first few sections of the distribution's manual before beginning to install. Mercifully, documentation is one of the project's priorities, and the information provided is clear, precise, and mostly complete.
section in particular could be used as a primer for a general understanding
of thin clients and network-boot workstations. However, the section might
benefit from more practical information about basic hardware setup. Common
hardware alternatives, such as workstations that boot from an external drive, could also be discussed in more detail, although that could easily become an endless task.
Administrators might also want to familiarize themselves beforehand with
what Debian calls flavors — the
installation sets for different circumstances. A main server is required
for administration and installing on other machines, but a complete setup
might consist of any number of secondary servers, workstations, thin clients, as well, perhaps, as roaming workstations (ones that are sometimes off the network). The installer also allows standalone installations for those who want to try Skolelinux without a network, perhaps on a student's notebook.
Each of these flavors differs in both the hardware requirements and the
software installed. For example, thin client servers may require two Ethernet
cards (one to connect to the main server and another to connect to the thin
clients), while the firewall and administrative tools, unsurprisingly, are
only installed on the server. Hard drive memory requirements are especially
different, with a minimum of 15GB required for a workstation, and 30GB for
the server. Similarly, the main server requires roughly 2GB of RAM for every 30 client machines. Since Skolelinux is often used to extend the useful years of older hardware, it is important to check that these varied requirements are met.
Once you start to install, the procedure is straightforward. However, pay attention to the final messages about hardware and software that is still unconfigured, such as Kerberos. These messages are probably unnecessary for most people likely to be installing Skolelinux, but they are useful reminders of what remains to be done before a fully functioning network exists.
Administration, user features, and software
As with installation, Skolelinux's administration features and software are best approached first from the manual and HOWTOs, or, for advanced topics, from the Debian Edu wiki.
Many of the administrative functions, such as installing general packages or permitting automatic security upgrades will be familiar to many general users of Linux. However, the documentation also includes such features as suggestions about other tools to use, a script for creating directories simultaneously in each user's home directory, and brief descriptions of lesser-known alternate software sources such as Debian's stable-updates and backports repositories. Like the installation instructions, this material provides an overview that even non-Skolelinux users might find helpful.
For administrators, the new features of the recent 6.0.4+r0 release
includes a new web-based LDAP administration tool. Other new features for
printers are designed to save power and reduce waste, such as a default
flush of print queues every night and having client machines automatically
turn off at night and on again in the morning. In addition, stopped printer
queues are restarted in an hour by default in case the printer was turned off accidentally.
For users, Skolelinux defaults to KDE, but GNOME, LXDE, and Sugar are also available as desktop environments. Installations include a much larger selection of software than standard Debian installations do, including KDE applications such as Amarok, Marble, and K3B, and other standard applications such as Inkscape, Scribus, and OpenOffice.org (not LibreOffice, since Debian stable has not yet switched).
Other installed software is heavily oriented toward education and creativity. The ever-popular Compris is included in the Favorites menu, while the Education menu includes everything from software for learning the alphabet and fractions to software for learning geometry and graph analysis. A drum machine and Rosegarden are included for musicians, as well as a chess game and at least two typing tutors.
Some might complain about the version numbers on Skolelinux's software,
since they are based on Debian stable, and some are far from the latest
available. However, Skolelinux has chosen stability over the cutting edge,
as system administrators would generally prefer.
In addition, as Reinholdtsen points out, the emphasis on stability minimizes the chances of a disruption of service during the school year. Although the emphasis may mean that drivers are unavailable for some newer hardware, he suggested that "we have found a reasonably good balance between stability and offering the latest software."
My one quibble with the selection of user software is that it covers the complete range of pre-university educational software. This choice is perhaps suitable for schools that cover a wide range of students. Yet inevitably it means that much of the software will be irrelevant for any specific class. Perhaps a solution might be the ability to install educational software by age or ability. But, in general, Skolelinux offers an impressive showcase of educational software.
Helping a veteran
Officially, Skolelinux is a Debian Pure Blend — a distribution that is a subset of general Debian and remains compatible with it. However, unless you are doing a standalone installation, setting up Skolelinux is not a trivial task. Given the number of flavors that it supports and the fact that multiple-machine setups are the norm, Skolelinux might more realistically be described as several distributions in one — including some with conflicting needs and priorities. The quality of the documentation mitigates this complexity to a large degree, but the instructions still contain assumptions about users' knowledge that may be unwarranted.
Still, what is noticeable about Skolelinux is not that there are gaps in the documentation, but that there are so few. In fact, another educational aspect of Skolelinux is that it could serve as a distribution for training sysadmins about networks and thin clients.
More than anything else, this reduction of complexity to clarity is what makes Skolelinux a pioneer and continuing innovator in free software and education but still relevant today. The project is currently fundraising, so one way to help this veteran project would be to make a donation to help ensure that its annual meeting of core developers can take place this year.
Comments (1 posted)
Since debian-devel is the perfect place for bad comparisons: you’re
saying that those wanting to replace cars by teleporters would have to
worry about traffic lights and speed limits.
-- Josselin Mouette
The current state of upstart in Debian is a reflection of the upstart
maintainers' respect for Debian and desire to not destabilize the
distribution by triggering an avalanche of package conversions that could
quickly take us past the point of no return for bit rot of our init scripts.
If there's a consensus in Debian that we should just push it in and Damn The
Ports, well, we could certainly do that.
Alternatively, instead of thousands of words being wasted in this thread,
interested DDs could help with finalizing the Policy change for how upstart
jobs should coexist with sysvinit scripts on the system.
-- Steve Langasek
Comments (none posted)
The Debian Apache maintainers have a few bits about the apache2 2.4
transition. The package is currently in Experimental and the maintainers
hope to get it into unstable in early April.
Full Story (comments: none)
Jan Hauke Rahm has a report on the recent front desk and Debian Account
Managers (DAM) meeting in Germany. "If you've followed what the
team, Enrico in particular, has been doing in the last months, you'll know
that there was some intention to replace the current NM web interface. Due
to security concerns that were brought to public attention just recently,
we decided that it's time to actually replace the code.
Full Story (comments: none)
Newsletters and articles of interest
Comments (none posted)
at Scientific Linux. "Scientific Linux has bundled a nice toolset for making custom spins the easy way. The package group is SL Spin Creation, and you get nice tools like LiveUSB Creator and Revisor (figure 2.) In fact, SL was designed with custom spins in mind; spins have their own unique features, but all of them are compatible. There is even a naming convention: Scientific Linux followed by the name of the institution. For example if I made one I would call it Scientific Linux LCR, for Little Critter Ranch.
Comments (11 posted)
ZDNet UK covers
the options available
with the recent release of Vector Linux 7.0
Light. "LXDE, the "Full" option, with the well-known and very
popular desktop manager, and pretty much the equivalent of a lot of other
LXDE distributions. Still "lightweight", compared to Gnome and KDE, but
certainly a lot more comfortable out of the box than the other options. In
fact, if you choose this option you also get the Medium option as well, so
you can switch back to plain Openbox if you want/need to or are just
" That's the heaviest of Light options, which also include
JWM "Barebones", IceWM "Light", and the Openbox "Medium" option.
Comments (none posted)
Page editor: Rebecca Sobol
Next page: Development>>