| |||||||||||||
I hope Mozilla funds Gnash developmentI hope Mozilla funds Gnash developmentPosted Feb 22, 2012 18:42 UTC (Wed) by marm (guest, #53705)In reply to: I hope Mozilla funds Gnash development by slashdot Parent article: No more Flash for Firefox on Linux
Sounds rather like a misfeature, or more specifically like optimizing for a very rare case.
Which is worse? Breaking a couple of Flash applications which use strange key combinations, or breaking ALL keyboard shorcuts for users of ALL Flash applications? The choice should not be hard :)
Besides, you can always add a "forward all keystrokes to this applet" toggle, which can be used in the exceptional cases.
(Log in to post comments)
I hope Mozilla funds Gnash development Posted Feb 22, 2012 23:04 UTC (Wed) by dlang (✭ supporter ✭, #313) [Link]
how can an application (flash or javascript) know what keystroke combinations are going to be grabbed by the browser?
I run in to this situation with a javascript app (shell in a box, running command line tools on a remote machine), on firefox the <cntl> T goes to the app, on chrome it goes to the browser.
which is better? having some portions of the app unavailable? or having some portions of the browser unavailable?
in my case it's more annoying to have the portions of the app unavailable, but I can understand how other people would want it the other way.
the particular command-line app that I run into trouble with most frequently pre-dates the start of firefox, let alone chrome, so you can't blame the app for using a 'reserved' key combination.
think about this a bit more, how can a browser know what key combinations are reserved by the Desktop Environment? what should happen if you have a conflict there?
I hope Mozilla funds Gnash development Posted Feb 23, 2012 20:26 UTC (Thu) by marm (guest, #53705) [Link]
> how can an application (flash or javascript) know what keystroke
> combinations are going to be grabbed by the browser?
I meant that the user should be the one to make the choice, not the application.
> in my case it's more annoying to have the portions of the app unavailable, > but I can understand how other people would want it the other way.
Then make it an option in browser preferences.
I hope Mozilla funds Gnash development Posted Feb 23, 2012 11:38 UTC (Thu) by loevborg (guest, #51779) [Link]
I agree. Also, it should arguably by default not be permitted to trap a basic shortcut like ^W as it presumably is impossible to trap Windows's Alt-F4, though you might add a flag for those who like to have Emacs-style "delete word" functionality inside a Flash object.
I hope Mozilla funds Gnash development Posted Feb 23, 2012 14:54 UTC (Thu) by Cyberax (✭ supporter ✭, #52523) [Link]
Uhm. Alt-F4 in Windows just sends a WM_CLOSE message to a window which can be ignored.
Probably you're thinking about ctrl-alt-del?
|
|||||||||||||