Posted Feb 3, 2012 10:19 UTC (Fri) by khim
In reply to: Shared pain
Parent article: XFS: the filesystem of the future?
Yes, there is room for improvement - there always is. Copying a mistake because it has some good features is not a wise move.
This depends on your goal, actually. If your goal is something theoretically sound, then no, it's not a wise move. If your goal is creation of something which will actually be used by real users then it's the only possible move.
(and yes, my beard is gray (or heading that way)).
My beard is not yet gray, but I was around long enough to see where the guys who did "wise move" ended. I must admit that they create really TRULY nice exhibits in Computer History Museum. Meanwhile creations of "unwise" guys are used for real work.
If your implementation unintentionally introduced some property and people started depending on it - it's the end of story: you are doomed to support said property forever. If you want to keep these people, obviously. If your goal is just to create something nice for the sake of art or science, then situation is different, of course.
This is basic fact of life and it's truly sad to see that so many Linux developers (especially the desktop guys) don't understand that.
to post comments)