LWN.net Logo

Schneier-based ideas work for me

Schneier-based ideas work for me

Posted Nov 10, 2011 9:37 UTC (Thu) by philipstorry (subscriber, #45926)
Parent article: A Periodic Table of password managers

When I was looking for a password safe, I fell towards the Schneier-based programs, because there's so many of them.

I chose to use an app not mentioned here - Debian/Ubuntu have a package called pwsafe (not to be confused with the iOS app mentioned here!), which uses version 1.x/2.x password safe databases of the Schneier school.

It's command-line only, which suits me.
(See http://packages.ubuntu.com/lucid/pwsafe for package details.)

I did install Password Gorilla as well, but that's mostly just for editing - in case I add or remove something to the wrong category, for example. Most password retrieval I do from the CLI, and most adding too.
(Set up an export on login to point to the password database you use by defauly, and it becomes super-easy!)

I did consider the fancy all-singing all-dancing cloud solutions, but none seemed to support Linux very well.

And frankly, how hard is it to sync one file via Dropbox/Ubuntu One/SpiderOak/$YourPoison?

That the file format is well understood and can be read on most platforms was really my main concern. Finding Passwd Safe on Android was the icing on the cake - now I have access to my password safe on my phone if I need it, which is great.
(Especially as I use the Ubuntu One Files app to grab the safe database file itself.)

Pretty interfaces and functionality are nice. As a Gnome user, I do of course use Seahorse/Gnome Keyring to record some passwords for applications. But that's a convenience, not my "primary place of record".

Whatever you choose, make sure you can access it from wherever you need to. Being able to access something via a bad interface when you need it trumps not being able to access it at all...


(Log in to post comments)

Schneier-based ideas work for me

Posted Nov 12, 2011 22:11 UTC (Sat) by mgedmin (subscriber, #34497) [Link]

I also use pwsafe (it protects my LWN password!). Unfortunately it's recently been removed from Debian and Ubuntu as unmaintained.

My smartphone until very recently was the Nokia N900. There was a Schneiderian clone called PasswordSafe that worked rather well (the only two bugs were a missing icon and a non-functional export).

I've tried to import my pwsafe database into Revelation, which claims support for it, but the import failed silently.

I'm now looking for a solution that would support both Ubuntu and the Nokia N9, and, ideally support the same format.

Schneier-based ideas work for me

Posted Nov 13, 2011 12:02 UTC (Sun) by philipstorry (subscriber, #45926) [Link]

Dang - I'm on Ubuntu LTS, so didn't know it had been removed. Thanks for letting me know.

I guess I have three options:
1. Learn C and maintain it myself (thus get it back into the distros)
2. Write my own "clone" in my own choice of language
3. Use something else

Luckily, having picked a format that's widely supported, three is at least an easy interim option until I can decide whether I want to do 1 or 2...

Good luck finding something to solve your problem.

Copyright © 2013, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds