LWN.net Logo

Liability of Users for Patent Infringement

Liability of Users for Patent Infringement

Posted Apr 24, 2011 19:02 UTC (Sun) by wahern (subscriber, #37304)
In reply to: Liability of Users for Patent Infringement by ThinkRob
Parent article: Google Linux servers hit with $5m patent infringement verdict (The Register)

Well, they didn't just sue Google. Here's a list of defendants from their Amended Complaint 2011-01-24. Don't infer anything about these defendants--other than Google--regarding the trial verdict.

  1. Softlayer Technologies, Inc.,
  2. CitiWare Technology Solutions, LLC,
  3. Google Inc.,
  4. Yahoo! Inc.,
  5. MySpace Inc.,
  6. Amazon.com Inc.,
  7. PayPal Inc.,
  8. Match.com, Inc.,
  9. AOL LLC,
  10. CME Group Inc.

Red Hat preemptively sued in 2009 for a declaratory judgment. Pacer charges per document so I can't figure out how out all of this unfolded (without paying), but here's the defendant list in Facebook's 2010-09-03 Amended Answer to Bedrock's crossclaim. I would guess these are all Red Hat customers impleaded by Bedrock.

  1. 1 & 1 Internet, Inc.,
  2. Rackspace Hosting, Inc.,
  3. Go Daddy Group, Inc.,
  4. Sungard Data Systems, Inc.,
  5. Whole Foods Market, Inc.,
  6. The Gap, Inc.,
  7. NYSE Euronext,
  8. ConAgra Foods, Inc.,
  9. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company,
  10. Facebook, Inc.,
  11. ConocoPhillips Company,
  12. Virgin America Inc., R.L. Polk & Co.,
  13. The Planet.com Internet Services


(Log in to post comments)

Liability of Users for Patent Infringement

Posted Apr 24, 2011 21:58 UTC (Sun) by orcmid (guest, #74478) [Link]

The link to justia.com provided by FOSSPatents earlier on this thread provides a lot of the soap opera: http://dockets.justia.com/docket/texas/txedce/6:2009cv002...

I got tired looking through it, and I don't think one can find actual exhibits or expert testimony.

What is interesting is that some of these companies have extensive web farms for their own operations. We know that Google's uses Linux. I presume these other users do also.

It is interesting that hosting services are included. I assume because they are engaging in commerce by leasing the use of LAMP-based hosted sites, etc. So my hosting service could easily make it onto this list, not to mention sites where I am an user (Facebook, amazon.com, etc.). Ick.

I suppose free cloud services (E.g., my Amazon Cloud Drive) may not be very free for long. And we all wait patiently to learn there has been a workaround that removes the infringing code from the Linux kernel.

Copyright © 2013, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds