LWN.net Logo

Surprising?

Surprising?

Posted Apr 24, 2011 16:08 UTC (Sun) by gmatht (guest, #58961)
In reply to: Android phones keep location cache, too, but it's harder to access (ars technica) by tetromino
Parent article: Android phones keep location cache, too, but it's harder to access (ars technica)

Revealing that a device arrives at my work at 9am and arrives at my home at 6pm regularly is more of a worry to me than revealing my IMEI. According to the article they delete endpoints, which I guess means that it isn't obviously trivial to get that data, but still not surprising to me if it can be reconstructed.


(Log in to post comments)

Surprising?

Posted Apr 25, 2011 9:51 UTC (Mon) by tialaramex (subscriber, #21167) [Link]

No, when they speak about endpoints they mean for Google's route planner.

Assuming you don't have some type of serious amnesia problem it's unlikely that you use Google's route planner to travel to and from work every day.

The geolocation data used to match WiFi hotspots, GPS locations and phone masts together doesn't have "endpoints" it's just a sea of possible correlations. If you find this to be a type of unbearable snooping, well, you can turn it off, but I'm afraid the rest of your life will be fairly miserable because tracking is inevitably going to become more and more pervasive over time.

In the larger picture we have a choice, much as societies have faced before. We can embrace the change and learn how to all live in the glass house, or we can fight tooth and nail and lose anyway. Sadly past experience suggests we'll probably choose to fight tooth and nail. Much better in most people's eyes to desperately try to lock the truth away than to face all the lies we tell ourselves and each other.

Surprising?

Posted Apr 25, 2011 12:48 UTC (Mon) by drag (subscriber, #31333) [Link]

If you want the truth it's helps to realize that phone companies track and record your movement anyways. If they don't sell that information it's only because nobody cares enough to pay for it.

Oh and your credit card (aka every major bank) collects and sells information about your purchasing habits. All personally identifiable, of course. Oh and mortgage applications are a big source of accurate information that is heavily traded.

Not to mention that your government collects information from your tax documentation, licensing applications, and other documentation your forced by law to fill out and sells that, too.

On top of that the government works closely with data collection corporations to ensure data accuracy.

Compared to all that Google is almost trivial.

Surprising?

Posted Apr 28, 2011 11:44 UTC (Thu) by nlucas (subscriber, #33793) [Link]

Doing something because others do it is not an argument.

There is a big difference between anyone with access to your phone to also have access to location information and some company who you make business with have access to information you had to share with them.

An application you download from the internet should not *EVER* have access to this information, unless enough BIG RED BUTTONS have been clicked and the phone is on a special mode only hackers know.

There should be a way to easily clear this cache, like the "recent files" list on a desktop. It's important private information and needs to be handled like that.

The "we are all in a big brother world" argument is ridiculous. There are (at least) some of us who don't have a facebook account, or even a blog, because they don't buy into the "world is a stage" and "everyone want's their 15 minutes of fame" philosophy.

Yeah, I know just by commenting on a public forum I'm giving away some of my private life into the internet, but there is a line for everyone.

Copyright © 2013, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds