LWN.net Logo

Enterprise distributions and free software

Enterprise distributions and free software

Posted Mar 8, 2011 2:10 UTC (Tue) by airlied (subscriber, #9104)
In reply to: Enterprise distributions and free software by ejr
Parent article: Enterprise distributions and free software

stability while adding new HW support is the main intersection.

I'm not saying its perfect but it less bad than bouncing to an upstream kernel., running Debian stable is fine on 2 yr old hw, even on hw coming out now Debian stable is already behind.


(Log in to post comments)

Enterprise distributions and free software

Posted Mar 8, 2011 2:48 UTC (Tue) by ejr (subscriber, #51652) [Link]

Ok, I'm guilty of not supplying all information. I run Debian testing+bits of unstable+tiny bits of experimental personally with rare issues. And for cluster installations, you only *need* the kernel+drivers up to whatever hardware is there, and you can pick whichever kernel + OFED level that is. Forklift upgrades still are the norm in the HPC world. Otherwise, I've been recommending a (tested, via slow VM emulating 4+ nodes) Debian testing snapshot every N months (often 12). That seems quite stable for *core* pieces in my little slice of the world. I imagine that other fixed-hardware installations are similar.

And in response to another comment, for *me* the VM performs much better with respect to my multithreaded jobs than older kernels do. But I also turn off swapping for HPC installations; if you swap, you loose the high-performance part. That does eat a little memory for monitors that *could* be swapped out, but it reduces the perturbation when those monitors happen to trigger during a compute job. Turning off swap doesn't turn off mmap-ing of large data sets, so it's not a huge deal for common apps and helps stop student mistakes from crippling the nodes. Setting the ulimit at a tested maximum keeps the OOM killer at bay (or seems to do so).

But I'm also stuck with RHEL given current employer restrictions. It's not terribly OpenMP-friendly, in my experience, leading to many people griping about how "Linux" sucks.

Copyright © 2013, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds