Easier way to get a license [LWN.net]

Easier way to get a license

Posted Jul 21, 2003 18:51 UTC (Mon) by lyda (guest, #7429)
In reply to: Easier way to get a license by dark
Parent article: SCO offers UnixWare licenses for Linux

i just did that. i post the following log:

kevin@owsla( 7:37)% rpm --checksig -v linux-2.4.13-21D.src.rpm
linux-2.4.13-21D.src.rpm:
MD5 sum OK: 475d343933d92e03c8143b4b2124e873
gpg: Signature made Wed 07 May 2003 22:42:45 IST using DSA key ID C4970D31
gpg: Good signature from "Caldera Security <security@caldera.com>"
gpg: Fingerprint: 2885 2E24 B0BD 3CD0 D063 203B 6E5B 99B2 C497 0D31
kevin@owsla( 7:37)% rpm -qip linux-2.4.13-21D.src.rpm [~]
Name : linux Relocations: (not relocateable)
Version : 2.4.13 Vendor: Caldera International, Inc.
Release : 21D Build Date: Mon 05 May 2003 09:26:30 IST
Install date: (not installed) Build Host: build311.ps.asia.caldera.com
Group : System/Kernel Source RPM: (none)
Size : 27986389 License: GPL
Packager : Ashish Kalra <ashishk@sco.com>
URL : http://www.kernel.org/
Summary : Linux kernel sources and compiled kernel image.
Description :
Linux kernel sources and compiled kernel images.
B-
kevin@owsla( 7:38)% cp linux-2.4.13.tar.bz2.sign src/rpmtree/SOURCES/linux-2.4.13.tar.bz2.sig
kevin@owsla( 7:38)% gpg --verify src/rpmtree/SOURCES/linux-2.4.13.tar.bz2.sig
gpg: Signature made Wed 24 Oct 2001 06:32:44 IST using DSA key ID 517D0F0E
gpg: Good signature from "Linux Kernel Archives Verification Key <ftpadmin@kernel.org>"
gpg: Fingerprint: C75D C40A 11D7 AF88 9981 ED5B C86B A06A 517D 0F0E

(Log in to post comments)

Easier way to get a license

Posted Jul 21, 2003 19:01 UTC (Mon) by allesfresser (subscriber, #216) [Link]

Well, let's think about this another way: sco says people have been infringing since 2001, and their kernel srpm is 2.4.13, which is from Oct. 2001. If that's the last version they say is legal, then let's have a look at the changelog for 2.4.14:

final:
- David Miller: sparc/scsi scatterlist fixes
- Martin Mares: PCI ids, email address update
- David Miller: revert TCP hash optimizations that need more checking
- Ivan Kokshaysky/Richard Henderson: alpha update (atomic_dec_and_lock etc)
- Peter Anvin: cramfs/zisofs missing pieces

pre8:
- Andrea: fix races in do_wp_page, free_swap_and_cache
- me: clena up page dirty handling
- Tim Waugh: parport IRQ probing and documentation fixes
- Greg KH: USB updates
- Michael Warfield: computone driver update
- Randy Dunlap: add knowledge about some new io-apics
- Richard Henderson: alpha updates
- Trond Myklebust: make readdir xdr verify the reply packet
- Paul Mackerras: PPC update
- Jens Axboe: make cpqarray and cciss play nice with the request layer
- Massimo Dal Zotto: SMM driver for Dell Inspiron 8000
- Richard Gooch: devfs symlink deadlock fix
- Anton Altaparmakov: make NTFS compile on sparc

pre7:
- me: reinstate "delete swap cache on low swap" code
- David Miller: ksoftirqd startup race fix
- Hugh Dickins: make tmpfs free swap cache entries proactively

pre6:
- me: remember to bump the version number ;)
- Hugh Dickins: export "free_lru_page()" for modules
- Jeff Garzik: don't change nopage arguments, just make the last a dummy one
- David Miller: sparc and net updates (netfilter, VLAN etc)
- Nikita Danilov: reiserfs cleanups
- Jan Kara: quota initialization race
- Tigran Aivazian: make the x86 microcode update driver happy about
hyperthreaded P4's
- me: shrink dcache/icache more aggressively
- me: fix up oom-killer so that it actually works

pre5:
- Andrew Morton: remove stale UnlockPage
- me: swap cache page locking update

pre4:
- Mikael Pettersson: fix P4 boot with APIC enabled
- me: fix device queuing thinko, clean up VM locking

pre3:
- René Scharfe: random bugfix
- me: block device queuing low-water-marks, VM mapped tweaking.

pre2:
- Alan Cox: more merging
- Alexander Viro: block device module race fixes
- Richard Henderson: mmap for 32-bit alpha personality
- Jeff Garzik: 8139 and natsemi update

pre1:
- Michael Warfield: computone serial driver update
- Alexander Viro: cdrom module race fixes
- David Miller: Acenic driver fix
- Andrew Grover: ACPI update
- Kai Germaschewski: ISDN update
- Tim Waugh: parport update
- David Woodhouse: JFFS garbage collect sleep

Anybody see any possible infringements?

Easier way to get a license

Posted Jul 21, 2003 19:03 UTC (Mon) by KaiRo (subscriber, #1987) [Link]

From this list of committers, who's working for IBM?

Easier way to get a license

Posted Jul 21, 2003 20:15 UTC (Mon) by sandy_pond (guest, #9734) [Link]

If that's the last version they say is legal

Go back and reread. They said no such thing.

Easier way to get a license

Posted Jul 21, 2003 20:55 UTC (Mon) by allesfresser (subscriber, #216) [Link]

I know they didn't say it explicitly--it's a synthesis: (a) They're still distributing 2.4.13 under GPL, (b) They say that people have been infringing since 2001, therefore, 2.4.13 seems to be the last version they aren't complaining about. They are very foggy in the extreme about their understanding of "Linux" in the first place--they can't seem to figure out the difference between the kernel and the aggregate collection of software in general--so the synthesis seemed as logical as anything else I can think of related to this psychotic case...

Easier way to get a license

Posted Jul 23, 2003 19:49 UTC (Wed) by cpm (guest, #3554) [Link]

Right, and they never do.
That sorta sits at the core
of the whole thing, doesn't
it?

Occam's razor applies here.