Sponsored link
Serve your customers, not your servers, with VERIO Linux VPS. Full-access test-drive here.
| Weekly edition | Kernel | Security | Distributions | Search |
| Archives | Calendar | Subscribe | Write for LWN | LWN.net FAQ |
Spam blocking with law
Spam blocking with law
Posted Jun 30, 2003 13:40 UTC (Mon) by mwilck (guest, #1966)In reply to: Spam blocking with law by giraffedata
Parent article: Spam blocking with greylisting
I don't want legislators handling the tricky definition of unsolicited commercial mail
What is so tricky about that? "Unsolicited" is absolutely clear - everything the recipient didn't ask for. "Commercial" shouldn't be so hard to define either.
The right solution would be to use the free market.
The solution you propose has nothing to do with the free market. It is just an different form of legislation. This can be very compared well to environmental legislation (instead of forbidding to dump waste, we assign a cost to it). This may or may not work better than a simple ban. In any case, the assigned cost is determined by legislation, not by the market.
"Proper targeting" requires you to have detailed knowledge about the recipient's interests (in your words, to know what sort of unsolicited commercial email the recipient would not consider "unwanted"). If that knowledge comes from person himself signing up to your newsletter - fine, it's not unsolicited, it's not spam. Otherwise, you could hardly have gathered that knowledge by legal means, at least not in Europe, because such information is considered private and confidential - you cannot have it unless the person himself has given it to you.
(Log in to post comments)
Spam blocking with law
Posted Jul 3, 2003 20:54 UTC (Thu) by khim (subscriber, #9252) [Link]
"Unsolicited" is absolutely clear - everything the recipient didn't ask for.
And that's exactly why it's so hard to define. This assumes you know what you asked for. When you are wisiting web site and it's asking you "Do you want to get our offers daily by e-mail?" and then when you refuse it asks you the same "Are you really sure you want to avoid getting our offers?" it's easy to click Yes or No two times and "ask" for mail.
Other thing: what about bug report or help requests ? I'm sometimes get requests for help from some peoples I never knew - they just happen to have the same problems with mars_nwe and/or SONY VAIO. I'm pretty sure I never asked for such mail but it's hardly can be named "spam".
So everything is far from black/white picture...