LWN.net Logo

The Open-PC Project Announced at GCDS 09 (KDE.News)

The Open-PC Project Announced at GCDS 09 (KDE.News)

Posted Jul 15, 2009 16:08 UTC (Wed) by pboddie (subscriber, #50784)
In reply to: The Open-PC Project Announced at GCDS 09 (KDE.News) by Cato
Parent article: The Open-PC Project Announced at GCDS 09 (KDE.News)

Be careful about labelling reported information as "the facts", if the assertion about "no concept of running 'applications' on your cell phone" is what you're referring to. I don't remember what Sean Moss-Pultz said now, and I'm totally aware of the ability to run applications even on my 2004 vintage Sony Ericsson, but there are considerable differences in terms of openness and vendor control between the classic Java ME or Symbian deployment scenarios and the kind of thing that Openmoko encourages.

One key distinction is that on an Openmoko-like device (or a cracked proprietary device) it's all about "your" applications, whether you write them yourself or get them from the Internet or wherever, not some provider's narrow stream of "authorised" downloads by "trusted partners" at however many euros, dollars or pounds a pop. Arguably, the assertion - however it was phrased - was about treating applications as applications, not services to be withheld or offered at the whim of your not-so-friendly provider. Attitudes certainly have changed since the iPhone was released and subsequently cracked, which was what Moss-Pultz said, as I recall.


(Log in to post comments)

The Open-PC Project Announced at GCDS 09 (KDE.News)

Posted Jul 16, 2009 10:29 UTC (Thu) by Cato (subscriber, #7643) [Link]

I have been installing 'unapproved apps' on my own smartphones since 2003 - first on Symbian (Ericsson P800), then on PalmOS (Treo). Only more recently have smartphone platforms (Symbian, iPhone, etc) tried to limit what apps could be installed, but it's been possible on some smartphone platforms such as PalmOS to install unapproved apps without any hassles.

I was reacting to the statement that OpenMoko somehow introduced the ability to install apps on mobile phones, which is clearly false - and probably not what Sean Moss-Pultz said.

Copyright © 2012, Eklektix, Inc.
Comments and public postings are copyrighted by their creators.
Linux is a registered trademark of Linus Torvalds