Ext4 breaking the promise of data=ordered ?

> Correct. Journaled data mode has the side-effect of maintaining a strict order for data writes, both with respect to each other (ie. writes in a given order will always preserve that order after a crash), and with respect to metadata such as timestamps. That's not a data integrity issue, but it is certainly a consistency issue; Unix semantics basically don't give you any consistency guarantees whatsoever unless the application is requesting consistent checkpoints via fsync/O_SYNC etc; but journaled data mode provides extra consistency nonetheless.

I think more than one person understands the _real_ semantics here.